9 ms·
This may be an obvious question on HN.. but.. how.. HOW can British people stand for this?
by sgt 13y ago
This may be an obvious question on HN.. but.. how.. HOW can British people stand for this?
- vixen99 13y agoAppalling that folk have to make a choice about whether to make it possible to view pornography or not? Parents certainly stand for it though you can argue whether the default should be the other way round. It's amazing how one's views on the subject of access to pornography can change once one is a parent.
- retube 13y agoYes absolutely. Most on HN are not parents. They will feel differently when their 9 year-old daughter clicks on a redtube link that someone posted somewhere.
- vidarh 13y agoI am a parent, and if anything it has made me much more vehemently opposed to filters like this, because I believe strongly that parents are using it as a poor excuse for not teaching their kids to deal with the internet properly, and also as when he is old enough to use the internet without active monitoring, he is also old enough to make a decision on what to view and read and will do so whether or not I try to filter. If I try to filter, though, I have every expectation he will come across much nastier stuff than what he'd otherwise likely seek out by his volition.
- finnw 13y agoMore likely they will never know that she clicked it
- darklajid 13y ago"Most on HN are not parents" Do you have numbers? I was very much surprised reading about family support/progressing in ones job aged 35+ etc. on this very board. Unless old readers drop out/don't return I'd guess that the number of parents here should statistically increase - and I don't think the number's insignificant. Start a poll? This parent here considers the idea of filtering content utterly wrong, but what really upsets me are your statements along these lines here: "Whiilst I may be a responsible parent and will turn on filters; many will not." K, not my native language and all. I'm certainly misparsing the sentence and you don't actually claim that being a reasonable parent and turning the filters on is connected, people NOT turning that thing on aren't reasonable parents? Because that's what I get out of that statement..
- vidarh 13y agoPersonally, as a parent, I have no problems with this filter for single people living alone or with a partner they are comfortable about discussing porn with. It is exactly in family situations I believe this filter is utterly morally wrong.
- snogglethorpe 13y ago> It's amazing how one's views on the subject of access to pornography can change once one is a parent. Sounds like an opt-in filter should satisfy your desires perfectly!
- girvo 13y agoNot all parents have that same view, though. I personally default to the "let the parents make the choice, and the state can butt out of it". I got that from my parents. :)
- eterm 13y agoAll that rhetoric about "Hard working familes"? That's because a large part of the voting public are indeed familes. They are also able to be manipulated by appealing to a sense they're not doing enough to protect their offspring.
- JonnieCache 13y agoDeference is our default setting. We never had a revolution here.
- bigfudge 13y agoWe've had our moments: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peasants'_Revolt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peasants'_Revolt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_I_of_England https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_I_of_England https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poll_Tax_Riots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poll_Tax_Riots I'd argue the British _had_ a default intolerance for authoritarianism, which seems only to have waned relatively recently. We didn't have a revolution because we already had Magna Carta.
- JonnieCache 13y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jarrow_March https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jarrow_March I was thinking the other day, how convenient it is that the various near-revolutions of our history are taught exclusively in primary school, before you're old enough to understand them.
- arethuza 13y agoAn interesting part of the Declaration of Arbroath is that Scots saw Kingship as being bestowed by the community rather than by God and if he didn't keep up the job they'd get rid of him and appoint someone better: "...we have been set free... by our most tireless prince, King and lord, the lord Robert... Yet if he should give up what he has begun, seeking to make us or our kingdom subject to the King of England or the English, we should exert ourselves at once to drive him out as our enemy... and make some other man who was well able to defend us our King" The Declaration does, of course, contain the words: "...as long as a hundred of us remain alive, never will we on any conditions be subjected to the lordship of the English. It is in truth not for glory, nor riches, nor honours that we are fighting, but for freedom alone, which no honest man gives up but with life itself." http://www.educationscotland.gov.uk/scotlandshistory/warsofindependence/declarationofarbroath/ http://www.educationscotland.gov.uk/scotlandshistory/warsofi...
- andygates 13y agoThey're playing the "motherhood and apple pie" card, and playing it hard. If in doubt, invoke Paedogeddon and push your legislation through. Agitating in favour of porn isn't a popular public opinion and the UK doesn't have the hardon for free speech that the USA does. Agitating against stupid broken censorship is a bit of a wonk issue - privacy people, law people, tech people.
- summerdown2 13y agoAs someone who marched in the largest peacetime protest ever in the UK, then saw the Iraq war happen anyway, I long ago gave up having any influence on the establishment.
- retube 13y agoBecuase I don't want hard core porn like the tubes being freely and instantly accessible to my kids. 1) No I am not "abdicating" my responsibilities as a parent. I will teach them appropriatre netiquette etc. There will always be other consumption vectors and work arounds, but I just don't want it shoved in their face, as is inevitable when it's just a click away. 2) Yes there are work-arounds to filters. But just becuase you can't perfectly block something doesn't mean you shouldn't take preventative measures. 3) I am not against porn. But access needs to be regulated. 4) The internet is a form of media like any other. We have restructions on buyng adult DVDs, magazines and cable channels. Why does internet delivered content qualify for special dispensation?
- adamors 13y ago> I just don't want it shoved in their face, as is inevitable when it's just a click away But you're perfectly content with shoving your views down everyone else's throat, right? If you want to block porn in your house you're free to do so. If you're not able to do that, either hire someone to do it for you or just don't allow your kids near the internet. Problem solved.
- retube 13y ago> But you're perfectly content with shoving your views down everyone else's throat, right? Oh I'm sorry, I'm not allowed to voice a differing opinion to the HN hivemind or your particular world view? I thought this site encouraged constructive discussion?
- adamors 13y agoQuit being so defensive, I'm not talking about expressing opinions on HN! I was commenting on your arguments for a filter that limits the web for other people. Like I said, you're free to limit your internet as much as you want. The problem is when you want to do it for everyone else.
- estel 13y ago
- acallaghan 13y agoI haven't. I've written to my (Tory) MP, asked all my friends to (and two have), repeatedly tried to win over the pro-filter people I know. I've also educated them on why it'll block sex education websites (like 6 months ago, not just today) and given examples of 8 year old kids I've taught that already have a private VPN, and give out access to their friends.