5 ms·
Unfortunately, this doesn't mean that it's secure. If someone breaks it, it means it's broken, but if nobody breaks it, it doesn't mean someone else can't break
by StavrosK 13y ago
Unfortunately, this doesn't mean that it's secure. If someone breaks it, it means it's broken, but if nobody breaks it, it doesn't mean someone else can't break it (or hasn't already).
- nwh 13y agoIt actually makes things worse really "no hackers can break this!" sounds good on paper, but it could just mean your adversary has more to gain by the system not being publicly broken.
- flurpitude 13y agoI don't see how it makes things worse. Surely it shows more if you gave hackers a big incentive to crack your encryption and they still didn't, compared to them not cracking it when there was no incentive. It is evidence that the reason they did not crack it was the difficulty of the problem, not just indifference.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- anonymoushn 13y agoA 73 day deadline on no notice to crack the system in a very specific way with no pay for people who succeed after the first is not a very big incentive. How many highly compensated security experts do you expect to stop doing their jobs for the opportunity to work for free?
- mikeyouse 13y agoAgreed, but the tone of the previous discussion was definitely more along the lines of "This could never work, you guys don't know what you're doing." If it proves resilient over 2.5 months of highly motivated attacks (motivated by both the money / "I-Told-You-So" factor), I think that's a fairly strong statement in their favor.
- jnbiche 13y agoExcluding an entity like the NSA, who cares nothing for $200,000 (literally a rounding error in their budget), but everything for the information available for the taking.
- loganu 13y agoWhile I agree with your point, immediately jumping to the NSA and their bottomless pool of resources and talent is kind of the new Godwin's law. Logan's law: In any given discussion tangentially related to security, the thing presented as "secure" will be soon declared "definitely not secure"... because...NSA.
- jnbiche 13y agoI actually agree with the motivation behind your argument -- it's ridiculous to pull out unknown NSA capabilities as a foil to every crypto argument. I just wanted to point out that there were times when money was not a very good motivator for someone who could break a given encryption system.
- capnjngl 13y agoSnowden's Law
- anonymoushn 13y agoNot quite 2.5 months.
- mikeyouse 13y agoHow time flies.. I read it as Mar 31, 2014 originally and didn't realize it was already Dec 18.. Edited to reflect that it's not really 4 months.
- killertypo 13y agoi have a day job and i'm not going to drop everything for the chance i won't make any money at all... told-you-so factor or not.