4 ms·
I don't think it's accurate to characterize the OP as criticizing (or being terrified by, for that matter) the freedom offered by Bitcoin as if freedom is a bad
by kevingadd 13y ago
I don't think it's accurate to characterize the OP as criticizing (or being terrified by, for that matter) the freedom offered by Bitcoin as if freedom is a bad thing. Rather, he argues (somewhat convincingly) that the freedom offered by Bitcoin is of most value to the people who are already rich enough (either in time, resources, or USD) to profit from speculation, asic mining, and other aspects of the Bitcoin market.
The freedom provided by this new financial system does nothing to enrich the people who are imperiled by the existing financial system; quite the opposite, the lack of regulations endangers them because they are not highly educated, rational financiers so they have increased exposure to risk/fraud.
- nostromo 13y agoI don't find it convincing at all. When I was in college, I hated banks. Once I bought a cup of coffee for $2 only to find I had racked up $40 worth of NSF fees accidentally. I'm sure this happens to poor folks all the time. Poor people often don't use banks because banks prey on the poor and often make them poorer. Why didn't I just use cash? Because I wanted to buy things online, accept payments from others, and didn't want to carry cash around all the time. If Bitcoin was less volatile, it would actually do a good job of solving some of the issues faced by poorer "underbanked" people.
- kevingadd 13y agoI'm with you on all the stuff about why banks are awful. They are awful. The problem is that it is an incredibly difficult leap to even imagine a potential universe where Bitcoin is better for the people currently victimized by banks. At present, it is massively, catastrophically worse for them. The volatility is only one of a numerous set of problems that apply there. I'm still interested to see how it will get used to solve real problems, but the protocol itself is at best a single tool that can be used to construct a system that actually helps the poor and the underbanked.
- baddox 13y ago> At present, it is massively, catastrophically worse for them. It has been less than four years since Bitcoin was invented. Looking at every major invention at age four, how many of them would be unequivocal successes for the group of people that eventually benefitted? Four years after the invention of computer networking, I'm sure computer networks were much worse than libraries for people doing research projects. Likewise with automobiles and travelers, airplanes and travelers, etc.
- comrade_ogilvy 13y agoThat sounds exactly like the kind of wishful thinking the OP is railing against. For "retail" folk who are having trouble navigating through regular life without getting screwed by their regular bank account, what does bitcoin offer? Less than nothing. Bitcoins may have their uses, but it is primarily an advantage to very sophisticated persons (or criminals).
- smtddr 13y ago>>If Bitcoin was less volatile, it would actually do a good job of solving some of the issues faced by poorer "underbanked" people. Bitcoin won't help poor people _directly_, but when it stabilizes I can think of at least a few ways it can help them indirectly. Another start-up company with a bitcoin backend challenging Western Union. All the not-wealthy immigrants who want to send money home without western-union's fees. Or maybe even bitcoin credit cards? Avoid the whole Visa/MasterCard infrastructure and whatever fees/rules it has. Of course, I still don't know how to deal with fraud & chargebacks..... so....
- baddox 13y agoI think there are several vastly different levels of "rich people." While I think Bitcoin right now mostly benefits the middle class with disposable income, I also think it is, at least conceptually, a huge threat to the very rich, specifically the people in the financial sector whose wealth comes from their close ties with the governments that control the world's monetary systems and economies.
- kevingadd 13y agoTechnically the only way Bitcoin can threaten the very rich is if it directly undermines the value of their assets. How exactly will it do that if, right now, any one of them can sink a huge amount of USD into amassing a Bitcoin stockpile (either by buying lots of ASICs or buying them directly)? There are literal examples of this already - the Winklevoss twins have claimed to own over 1% of all Bitcoins, effectively converting some of their massive USD wealth into BTC. Even if you were to undermine the existing monetary systems, any rich person that saw it coming would easily be able to amass a giant BTC stockpile and ride it out. In that scenario, they would not stand to lose very much in a BTC transition, as long as they saw it coming before USD's value was completely destroyed. The 'very rich' can afford to spend extravagantly to acquire bitcoins, and can afford to do so at 'a loss' if they actually have some good reason to convert money from other currencies to BTC. The average poor or middle-class person who has bitcoins to sell will be unlikely to turn down an offer to buy BTC at above market prices or similar other arrangements. You can argue that Bitcoin is a threat to the revenue streams that the 'very rich' rely on to become wealthy and stay wealthy; however, it is mostly a threat in that it displaces those revenue streams. Speculators that currently work in things tied to USD can just as easily do their speculation against BTC; you do nothing to put those people out of work. Investors, likewise, are not somehow directly threatened by a Bitcoin-based economy. It's just currency to them.
- baddox 13y agoWhy do you think banks and governments have been so hostile to Bitcoin? Do you think it is the desire to protect the citizens for their own good, or is it to maintain control? For a quick benchmark, I would also ask a similar question: why do you think the US government spies on its citizens?