4 ms·
Don't worry, based on their past behaviour I'm pretty sure they'd have managed to refund him the dollar value if the price of Bitcoin skyrocketed.
by makomk 13y ago
Don't worry, based on their past behaviour I'm pretty sure they'd have managed to refund him the dollar value if the price of Bitcoin skyrocketed.
- EGreg 13y agoFunny dynamics for bitcoin to be used as a currency For now its swings are like the Zimbabwe dollar
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- AnneOminous 13y agoThis isn't a failure of Bitcoin. It's a failure of the market. Bitcoin has an approximate "intrinsic value", which in economic terms is a bit above the cost of mining. Current market price has been very far from that. Bitcoin market right now is pretty much the definition of a bubble. Beware. In a "bubble" market, your money can disappear overnight. But again: that's not Bitcoin's fault. It's the fault of idiots vastly and irrationally driving up market prices. This is really a textbook lesson in why Wall Street does not represent the "real" exonomy.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Bitcoin has an approximate "intrinsic value", which in economic terms is a bit above the cost of mining. The current cost of mining is a rough replacement cost of bitcoin (and thus, in a sane market, ought to be a ceiling on its market value, since if the exchange cost is higher than that, you are better of mining then buying), but since mining isn't inherently reversible its not an intrinsic value.
- AnneOminous 13y agoQuote: "...but since mining isn't inherently reversible its not an intrinsic value." It IS "value", because the resources used for mining have measurable value, and can be traded for things other than Bitcoins. It may be an indirect measure of value, but it's still a measure of value.
- 21echoes 13y agocarbon emissions from a coal plant do not have the "intrinsic value" of the coal that produced them. bitcoins from a miner's computer do not have the "intrinsic value" of the electricity and silicon that produced them.
- AnneOminous 13y agoThe exhaust from your Chevy also doesn't have the "intrinsic worth" of the oil that it ultimately came from, either. Nor does the electricity from my solar cells have the "intrinsic worth" of the silicon they were made of. So what? That is about the farthest thing from a valid analogy I've seen in a long time.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> The exhaust from your Chevy also doesn't have the "intrinsic worth" of the oil that it ultimately came from, either. The difference between it and Bitcoin here is that no one is claiming that automotive exhaust has intrinsic worth due to the resources expended to produce it.
- AnneOminous 13y agoNo, you're still not getting it. The VALUE is not indirect (i.e., extrinsic). The METHOD OF MEASUREMENT is indirect. Those are two different things. One does not imply the other. If I measure the "worth" of your automobile in units of "old Chrysler convertibles", that doesn't mean your automobile has any more or less economic value than if I measure it in helium balloons. The method of measurement (if it's done properly) does not affect the actual value. In the case of Bitcoin, it CAN be traded directly for goods, not dollars. There is nothing REAL distinguishing it from any other commodity, such as rice. The value is roughly equivalent to the cost of production + distribution. I take that back. There IS one difference, but (at this time) it is minor: that is the ultimately limited supply, but that isn't even remotely close enough yet to affect a RATIONAL market. An EXTRINSIC value, on the other hand, and to use Wikipedia's example, is like the "value" of a song played on a guitar. It has its own subjective and economic values, but that is completely separate from the cost of manufacturing the guitar. This is NOT even remotely the same situation as Bitcoin.
- dllthomas 13y ago"and thus, in a sane market, ought to be a ceiling on its market value, since if the exchange cost is higher than that, you are better of mining then buying" Modulo time preferences... But yes, bitcoin's intrinsic value is that it is the only method to pay transaction fees to have work done on your behalf by the bitcoin network. I don't know how to price that, though.
- Buge 13y agoHave you heard of that happening? Here some cases where coinbase uses the original price even after a price increase: http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1qlvgj/psa_rest_easy_with_coinbase/ http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1qlvgj/psa_rest_eas... http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1qlvgj/psa_rest_easy_with_coinbase/cde69au http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1qlvgj/psa_rest_eas... http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1cxmuf/bought_5_btc_from_coinbase_at_65usd_and_received/ http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1cxmuf/bought_5_btc... And in this current case, coinbase used the new price even though the price decreased. So whether the price increases or decreases, coinbase is taking a loss and gives the money to the consumers.