5 ms·
To all of you who say that Bitcoin shouldn't be regulated - this is what it results in. If it was any regulated financial deal - say, purchase of stock or Yen
by PeterisP 13y ago
To all of you who say that Bitcoin shouldn't be regulated - this is what it results in.
If it was any regulated financial deal - say, purchase of stock or Yen - then there are clear rules on how to handle that, namely, you'd be entitled to at least compensation for any decrease between the 'locked' price at the agreed settlement date and the real settlement, whenever it may happen, and the interest for the period. Repeated such situations would result in a rapid audit to verify if they really have enough assets to pay out all their debts, and if not, shut them down immediately.
Now you're quite screwed, while coinbase has taken a profit on this (and probably other) deals by delaying these settlements. And what are you going to do if you don't get all the losses covered? Your options are quite limited.
- ig1 13y agoFrom what I recall from when I worked in FX trading, settlement dates were set by contract and not by regulations. As an aside calculating settlement dates for currencies is actually pretty hard because different currencies have different rules, observe different holidays and roll-over differently. When calculating for a cross-pair you basically need to find the first settlement date which is a valid trading date for both currencies (except some currency pairs which have special rules).
- PeterisP 13y agoThere's no problem with setting settlement dates - the original poster had a clearly agreed settlement date with Coinbase. The problem is with risks and consequences of the counterparty failing to deliver on the settlement date.
- jonpaul 13y agoNo way. Regulation won't solve these sort of things. It will just make the barrier to entry that much higher. Now people have a voice more so than ever before. If companies don't act appropriately, people can post stories and complaints online. The companies reputation will then suffer. This is exactly what's happening here.
- bushido 13y agoLost reputation is limited to the life of the corporation, going literal here, but once a corporation cease to exist, rarely does the reputational consequences affect the lives and businesses running them, which is usually thanks to regulation and laws. In this paradigm, where anonymity is rampant, reputation is just a word. As an anonymous entity/non-entity has no consequences to their actions.
- bonemachine 13y agoIf companies don't act appropriately, people can post stories and complaints online. The companies reputation will then suffer. Ah, Libertopia! It's almost upon us, Comrades!
- mseebach 13y agoYes, and are you 100%, no strings attached, free to not participate if you are not comfortable with the rules. The stupid libertarians get their stupid pie-in-the-sky currency and you get to sit back with a bowl of popcorn (purchased with a government-secured currency of your choice) and enjoy the show.
- jnbiche 13y agoGreat, now if you could please convince the government to adopt your attitude. Ridicule and childish insults I don't mind, just men with guns coming to lock me up if I don't run my business in the way you think it should be run.
- bonemachine 13y agoYou know, this whole "men with guns" thing is a pretty tired, and basically vapid analogy. The whole point that libertarians fail to realize -- and one of the most basic and obvious lessons of thousands of years of recorded human history is that one way or another, we're all stuck on this same, leaking boat together. And we're just going to have to find a way to cooperate on some basic level. Else things start to get really inefficient and wasteful -- or potentially really, really ugly and violent -- really, really fast. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner's_dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner's_dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
- baddox 13y ago> To all of you who say that Bitcoin shouldn't be regulated - this is what it results in. My interpretation is precisely the opposite of yours. Every other method to exchange bitcoins and USD has been shut down (or at least had its US presence shut down). Coinbase nearly has a monopoly in the United States (I say nearly, because there are certainly still ways to get on other exchanges based in other countries, they're just much more difficult). Coinbase, from what I can tell, must have some political advantage that allows them to stay in service.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- baddox 13y agoI'm skeptical of that. Coinbase is easily as well-known as Bitfloor (though granted, I don't have data on transaction volume), and certainly more popular and active than the guy who has creating physical bitcoin coins: http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2013/12/casascius/ http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2013/12/casascius/
- walden42 13y agoThe fact that coinbase has bad customer service is not new. You and anyone else upset about it can simply not use their service. Adding regulation only makes the barrier to entry worse for new companies. You can be sure that Coinbase would be (one of) the only companies who'd be able to exchange bitcoins so easily.
- mathattack 13y agoNow you're quite screwed, while coinbase has taken a profit on this (and probably other) deals by delaying these settlements. And what are you going to do if you don't get all the losses covered? Your options are quite limited. Do we know that this was case of Coinbase taking a free option, versus incompetence? My thought... If they lock in a price, they are taking a risk. There's no risk-free arbitrage. They could wait and hope for the price to go down, and make some money, but they'd also owe money if the price went up. This does harm the customer, but if it's not a daytrading platform, you can't fault them if they honor the original price no matter what direction it turns. The real concern is if this happens to a lot of trades at once, the firm could go out of business honoring the original price.
- makomk 13y agoTheir lock in isn't worth the paper it's printed on, though - they reserve the right to cancel transactions up to the point bitcoins are actually delivered, and frequently do if the price goes enough (or just refuse to offer locked-in prices if it's obvious the price is rising).
- mathattack 13y agoIf they can cancel pre-delivery, it's a very different story, because then it can be interpreted as a free option.
- jnbiche 13y agoNo, wrong. The reason people have to put up with Coinbase's shenanigans^, is because of the super intense regulations in this sector. Those of us who would take customer money more seriously (and who would have refused additional customers much earlier) also take legal liabilities more seriously, particularly the legal liabilities of running an unlicensed money transmission business. If these regulations weren't so onerous, a dozen more of us would have jumped into the arena, and the one of us who gave the best customer service would be the market leader. Instead, buyers are stuck with Coinbase. ^ Not suggesting anything purposely illegal -- just incompetence combined with too much business. Yet another reason regulation is hurting everyone here: less regulation would have left Coinbase left overwhelmed with so much business (since there would be more competing businesses).
- PeterisP 13y agoLowering standards and allowing a larger number of competitors could bring in a better alternative to Coinbase, thus benefitting users and allowing them to get better service. However, it would also bring in a bunch of far worse companies, including purposely illegal ones. I'm fairly sure that the average 'quality' would go down even more. There could be a benefit to the more careful users, but consumers in general would simply get defrauded on scale. If the current quality level is unacceptable, then IMHO it is appropriate to say "guarantee X or get out of the business". Even if it results in 100% everyone getting out of the business - then it simply means that the potentially profitable niche will be waiting until someone is ready to do it properly.
- jnbiche 13y agoThere already are a bunch of far worse companies, including illegal ones. You see, the illegal ones operate anonymously and completely disregard the laws. The only ones the laws are keeping out are honest businesses who do pay attention to the laws, and who would provide strong competition to Coinbase.