3 ms·
They did control for temperature. They mandated mice be kept between 20C and 26C, which is between 68F and 78F. Mice live in houses, that's the temperature of
by saalweachter 13y ago
They did control for temperature. They mandated mice be kept between 20C and 26C, which is between 68F and 78F. Mice live in houses, that's the temperature of houses.
31C is 88F. It's not absurdly hot, but it's hot enough that it's surprisingly hot to me.
- mikeash 13y agoControl for temperature doesn't mean "control the temperature". It means to set up the experiments such that you can detect the effect of temperature. Basically, how did they decided that 20-26C was the right range? If it wasn't by testing differences between mice at colder and warmer temperatures, then they weren't controlling for temperature.
- saalweachter 13y agoYes it does. Controlling a variable means setting up the experiments such that the variable doesn't influence the results. This is typically done by making sure it is the same in both the experimental and control group. Experiments typically control a large number variables, and only vary a small number (ideally, one).
- jonlucc 13y agoMice in a particular experiment tend to be housed in the same room or same rack, with enough circulation in the room to hopefully assure a homogeneous temperature in the room. Therefore, the control animals were likely right next to treatment animals. In this way, one could reasonably say that variations between the groups is not due to the way they were housed. Many other things that are controlled in housing include their feed, bedding, access to water, number of animals in a cage, etc.
- mikeash 13y agoThank you both, I wasn't thinking clearly. I was thinking of the sort of "control for" that involves accounting for differences between groups, but totally spaced on the part where you can just "control for" something by ensuring it's the same.
- collyw 13y agoSurely mice live outside as well. I mean, I assume there were mice around before humans evolved enough to build houses, and heat them.
- loceng 13y agoPerhaps I just don't know the correct terminology, though you can have multiple control groups, no? That is what I was meaning, I realize I wasn't very clear.
- saalweachter 13y agoYeah, you can have multiple groups in the study, but you have to pick them somehow. Since most scientists aren't just sadistic mouse-torturers, you're picking groups that you think will tell you something. If you're testing a medicine, you might have one control (no-treatment) group, one group which receives whatever the current conventional/best drug is for the particular ailment, and one group which receives your new therapy. It's useful to see if your new therapy is any more effective than the old, in addition to seeing if it is effective at all. On the other hand, prior to this experiment, there was no reason to suspect that mice at 31C would be significantly different than mice at 25C. So why waste time, money, and mice by re-doing everything at 31C? Remember, things don't end well for the control group just because they're the no treatment group: they've got to be killed and autopsied at the same rate as the experimental group. When the study says "chemical X resulted in a 35% increase in tumors", they know that because they cut open both the experimental and control group, counted their tumors, weighed them, compared them, and came up with that number of 35%. Prior to this experiment, there was no reason to think that mice at 31C would be any different to mice at 25C, any more than you would expect mice wearing funny hats to be any different than mice without. Would you expect scientists to run a second control group of mice wearing funny hats, and slice them open and count their tumors, just in case it ended up being different?
- Florin_Andrei 13y agoMice are small. Their surface / volume ratio is MUCH higher. They lose heat a lot faster than we do.
- saalweachter 13y agoAll other things being equal, yeah. But while a six foot tall mouse would lose heat way slower than a normal sized mouse, people and mice have different amounts of fat and fur. It's not obvious to me a priori that mice would have a different optimum temperature range. I mean, England barely ever has a high of 31C, and there are plenty of mice there. I wouldn't suspect that every mouse in England is immunocompromised.
- ljf 13y agoOther points - mice rarely have bedding in their cages which they use to increase their body heat, and also to sleep in, which allows them to lower their temperature without ill affect (why many animals sleep through the night. Nests in cages mean mice can't be observed, so are usually not provided. Mice are kept lean, so have limited body fat for warmth. Mice are kept in overly-well ventilated cages, which adds to the cold felt. Many mice are bred for limited or low fur, which again means they need a higher mean temperature to stay warm. Lastly the cages encourage non wild behaviour, and are rarely enriched with toys, or have long spaces in which to run, which the animals also use to mediate their body temperature.
- gohrt 13y agoBasically, doing "normal" biology/psychology experiments "lab" mice is sort of like doing those experiments on astronauts living on the moon. A rather horrid mis-approximation of the experience/behavior of normal population. The moden scientific laboratory design puts so much emphasis on precision (cages, diets, etc, for consistent experimental outcomes), that it fails miserably at accuracy (similarity to what non-experimental individuals)
- saalweachter 13y ago