4 ms·
Gorgeous, beautifully made - but god damn EXPENSIVE for the specs. Sheesh! (disc: I own an iMac 27'' but will not be buying apple computers again)
by sergiotapia 13y ago
Gorgeous, beautifully made - but god damn EXPENSIVE for the specs. Sheesh! (disc: I own an iMac 27'' but will not be buying apple computers again)
- mikeash 13y agoThe breakdowns I've seen have the component cost much in line with the price being charged.
- pc86 13y agoTo what degree? I'd love to see one of these breakdowns if you have a link.
- mikeash 13y agoI'm having trouble finding anything "official", I think I may have just seen them in comments here and elsewhere. It's all a bit imprecise as well, since not all of the components are completely clear (e.g. the GPUs are some custom Apple-specific model, which appears to have a generic PC equivalent, but it's not completely solid). My vague recollection is that the GPUs alone are something like $700 each, and you get two, and the rest goes from there. Depending on the assumptions you make, you can get a $3,000 Mac Pro costing more than $3,000 for an equivalent PC, or less. Just beware of people comparing the Mac Pro with builds using non-Xeon CPUs, gaming GPUs, etc. Not that there's anything wrong with that sort of configuration, and personally I wish Apple offered some middle ground with high-end consumer components, but it doesn't give a good guide to what this actual machine costs to put together.
- makomk 13y agoYeah, it's probably not bad value for money if you need exactly one of the combinations of components they offer, with nothing more and nothing less. Which basically means someone who needs an expensive Xeon workstation-class CPU, dual AMD workstation class GPUs, and a fast SSD for the OS, but only 12-16GB of RAM and no RAID array or expansion cards. If you want anything more or less than that, you'll end up overpaying or just plain not being able to get it at all. For instance, it's overpriced if you don't actually need two workstation GPUs, or if you need more RAM than the standard amount, or if you don't actually need a Xeon CPU, or if you have different storage requirements. Expansion cards? Pay through the nose for new Thunderbolt replacements or forget it.
- mikeash 13y agoI agree, and that makes complaints about lack of options completely legitimate. But that's a completely different complaint from saying it's overly expensive for what's actually included. That's what was being said in the comment I replied to. "Too expensive for my needs" is not the same as "too expensive for what's included".
- dylandrop 13y agoYeah, I thought it would be CHEAPER than their laptops, at least base price. I could be wrong, but isn't that how most desktop PCs are priced? I mean of course the specs are much, much better, but I thought you pay a premium for the laptop body, and so the desktop is naturally cheaper.
- mikeash 13y agoThat's true, and that's why Apple's cheapest desktop (the Mac Mini) is cheaper than Apple's cheapest laptop. The Mac Pro, however, is not designed to be cheap. It has Xeon CPUs, ECC RAM, two high-end GPUs, large amounts of RAM, etc. The Mac Pro is built to be powerful. If you want cheap, you want an iMac or a Mac Mini.
- seiji 13y agobut will not be buying apple computers again Why not? There aren't any alternatives.
- sergiotapia 13y agoI don't have the need for mobility anymore. I work from home. I can build myself a beast of a machine with 60% of the cost of this desktop or an iMac. Don't get me wrong, I love my iMac but it beachballs way too often; enough for me to notice - and it's an iMac from Feb 2013. To me that's sort of unacceptable given the price I paid for it. I then built myself a desktop with $1000 and it's a beast, full SSD 16GB ram the works. Never stalls, always keeps up with my chain of thought. You would think it doesn't make the difference but it does and it's noticible.
- seiji 13y agoThat's a great reason. I did the same back in 2009 when an iMac couldn't support the displays I wanted along with CPU/RAM requirements. I find my computing drifts when I do that — I end up with a lot more flac music that doesn't port back to iTunes easily. But these days, I can grab a rMBP, hook up three 27" external monitors (plus the built in 15" HiDPI display, plus the rMBP can use an AppleTV as an external monitor, not just a mirror now), have a 1 TB internal PCIe flash setup, have 16 GB RAM, and four 2.6GHz (~8 with HT) cores to do my bidding. Plus, the Linux box was about two feet tall and acted as a noisy space heater even in the summer. :-\ (but, I had it crammed full of 2 TB drives. but, rMBP has USB 3 and Thunderbolt for easy expansion. It's more difficult for me to justify large computers for non-compute-intensive tasks these days.)
- kayoone 13y agothats true and very compelling, still your 15inch rMBP is at least twice as expensive as a more powerful desktop.
- seiji 13y agoBut, it's smaller, outputs less heat overall (though, the keyboard is often too hot to touch if you rest your hands on keys or—god forbid—if you accidentally touch metal between keys), and it sometimes stalls all display output for 30 to 60 seconds at a time while running all cores at 100% for no discernible reason at all between once a week or 15 times a day depending on its mood. Let's see your tower do that. Stockholm Computing Syndrome? As far as price: company bought it. Always change jobs right before an Apple hardware refresh event. If it wasn't essentially "free" from my end, I'd have gone with a 27" iMac.
- uladzislau 13y agoWhy you won't buy Apple - too expensive for the specs or you had some other issues?
- sergiotapia 13y agoYes it's too expensive for the specs.