11 ms·
Lab Mice Are Being Kept Too Cold, Apparently
- loceng 13y agoDid anyone else assume that temperature would be something they'd realize they need to control for? I would even suggest they should have a control group with a fluctuating temperature, as humans go through temperature fluctuations - and perhaps even seasonally alter temperatures.
- mhb 13y agoThen there's also humidity, altitude and who knows what else.
- GotAnyMegadeth 13y agoGravity
- headShrinker 13y agoNot gravity unless they're studying mice in space with some expectation that the subjects are unaffected by the vast different in gravitational pull.
- drivers99 13y ago"Apparent gravity on the earth's surface varies by around 0.7%, from 9.7639 m/s2 on the Nevado Huascarán mountain in Peru to 9.8337 m/s2 at the surface of the Arctic Ocean" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_of_Earth#Variation_in_gravity_and_apparent_gravity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_of_Earth#Variation_in_g...
- GotAnyMegadeth 13y agoThat's what I was going for, gravity has probably almost never been controlled for.
- loceng 13y agoMight as well add magnetic field to the list. In the odd circumstance it's possible there could be a large amount of power / electricity in wiring nearby, creating a magnetic field that's different than other test groups, etc..
- gosub 13y agoventilation, illumination type and intensity, human presence.
- saalweachter 13y agoThey did control for temperature. They mandated mice be kept between 20C and 26C, which is between 68F and 78F. Mice live in houses, that's the temperature of houses. 31C is 88F. It's not absurdly hot, but it's hot enough that it's surprisingly hot to me.
- mikeash 13y agoControl for temperature doesn't mean "control the temperature". It means to set up the experiments such that you can detect the effect of temperature. Basically, how did they decided that 20-26C was the right range? If it wasn't by testing differences between mice at colder and warmer temperatures, then they weren't controlling for temperature.
- saalweachter 13y agoYes it does. Controlling a variable means setting up the experiments such that the variable doesn't influence the results. This is typically done by making sure it is the same in both the experimental and control group. Experiments typically control a large number variables, and only vary a small number (ideally, one).
- jonlucc 13y agoMice in a particular experiment tend to be housed in the same room or same rack, with enough circulation in the room to hopefully assure a homogeneous temperature in the room. Therefore, the control animals were likely right next to treatment animals. In this way, one could reasonably say that variations between the groups is not due to the way they were housed. Many other things that are controlled in housing include their feed, bedding, access to water, number of animals in a cage, etc.
- mikeash 13y agoThank you both, I wasn't thinking clearly. I was thinking of the sort of "control for" that involves accounting for differences between groups, but totally spaced on the part where you can just "control for" something by ensuring it's the same.
- mapt 13y agoThe hazard here is not inside a fully parallel blinded trial with controls in the same environment, but in comparison and replication of studies, as well as sequential studies where the lab temperature changed. If quite minor, to human senses, changes in temperature significantly affect tumor formation, then up until now that's been a huge noise source in cross-study comparison, and temperature should be at least recorded precisely over time for all future tox studies.
- tehwalrus 13y agonot necessarily so - the article mentions that the cold inhibits two specific immune cell types; discovered drugs may only be effective in combating tumors arising from these specific deficits, which aren't relevant in real scenarios, i.e. a systematic error from cold in all studies.
- aroch 13y agoI'll have to double check, but I believe we keep our mouse room at ~25ºC (+/- 5%). 31C for housing seems very high and probably well outside mean temperatures for native habitat
- bryne 13y agoApparently not.
- brianbreslin 13y agoWhen I was in middle school my science fair project involved the temperature controls for experiments on electric fish. I ended up getting a byline in science mag for the project, as it had thrown into question a lot of existing studies that hadn't controlled for temperature.
- contextual 13y agoEven putting aside the moral and ethic issues, how can animal testing be allowed to continue when the studies are rife with bias and error? Officials at America's National Institutes of Health (NIH) state over three quarters of all published biomedical findings are irreproducible due to fraud and incompetence. Moreso, the number of retractions has grown over tenfold in the past decade - but it's only 0.2% of the 1.4 million papers published in academic journals. The studies that were retracted were only done so when fundamental flaws were exposed by others. Many more false studies go on unnoticed and continue to be referenced. Worse of all, 90 percent of drugs that were "successfully" tested on animals then failed in human trials. EDIT: It should be a criminal offence for researchers to subject animals to harm and death and produce fraudulent papers. Sources: http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21588057-scientists-think-science-self-correcting-alarming-degree-it-not-trouble http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21588057-scientists-t... http://www.popsci.com/article/science/how-get-rid-animal-testing http://www.popsci.com/article/science/how-get-rid-animal-tes...
- angersock 13y agoI really, really, really hate having to make this argument, but: Would you rather that all the drugs that didn't succeed in animals fail in humans first?
- contextual 13y agoIf humans were tested, many of these badly designed and fraudulent experiments would have never been done in the first place.
- angersock 13y agoA well-designed experiment that kills the subjects still kills the subjects. I'd rather that those subjects not be humans. I agree that the experimental rigor ought be higher, mind you.
- munificent 13y agoThen how would we have found the 10% of drugs that did succeed?
- ry0ohki 13y agoAm I reading this wrong, or has something else been accidentally discovered: Being cold/stressed out causes tumors?
- craigyk 13y agodepends. a lot of these mice are specific breeds designed to make it at least feasible to perform experimentation. It's common to use mouse lines that have extremely deficient immune systems. Otherwise there would be almost zero chance of tumor cells transferred from a different species (i.e. human) being able to grow on the mouse for study.
- jonlucc 13y agoThis is a very good point. It is important for non-researchers to know that when you want to do a mouse (or rat, dog, or non-human primate) study, you have to decide what particular strain of mouse to buy. There are MANY options from Harlan, Charles River, etc, and each strain has its own genetic composition. Some of the strains are intentionally inbred, or intentionally outbred. I think this variation might also be more important than some people are giving credit for. It is entirely possible to run a mouse study twice, confirming the results. Then, you can run the same protocol in a different strain and get no results or different results. Then, you have to try to understand which strain might be more applicable in a human population.
- knowtheory 13y agoI'd be super uncomfortable with anybody asserting that conclusion. What the quote in the original article says is that they have data that in a preliminary fashion supports the hypothesis that being cold (and trying to keep warm) suppresses a mouse's ability to fight off tumor growth. That is very different from saying cold/stress causes tumors.
- DougWebb 13y ago"causes" is the troubling word there. From what I've read, in most people and animals tumors are growing all of the time due to cell replication defects, but normally the immune system gets rid of them. Cancer, as a disease, isn't "your body is making tumors", it's "your immune system isn't keeping up with your tumors". From that point of view, anything which makes your immune system less effective "causes" cancer by making it harder for your immune system to kill tumor cells faster than they occur. Being cold all of the time, or being subjected to any type of chronic stress, certainly seems like it could do that.
- qwerty_asdf 13y agoDoes PNAS realize that their acronym is ridiculous and hilarious? Was that done on purpose?
- Florin_Andrei 13y agoIt took me a while to realize why you said that. I think you've been over-sensitized by spending too much time in certain regions of the Internet. When the only tool in your possession is a hammer, everything looks like a nail. When most of your informational input is of a certain nature, everything else tends to relate to it.
- colanderman 13y agoNo. There is only one way to pronounce "PNAS" (other than spelling it), and it sounds exactly like "penis". Not "cock", "dong", "member", "wang", or any other arguably childish euphemism. It sounds exactly like the proper English noun for male genitalia. And this has nothing to do with you me or the parent thinking it sounds like "penis". EVERYBODY WE TALK TO will think we're saying "penis". Believe me, I get this enough with Coq (the theorem prover) and "cock"'s merely slang.
- qwerty_asdf 13y agoI can't wait until the National Academy of Sciences holds additional proceedings on the seventh planet in our solar system!
- OneOneOneOne 13y agoThey can play the 6th movement from Holst's "The Planets" at their opening ceremony Uranus, the Magician http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Planets#Structure http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Planets#Structure
- chc 13y agoUnless you're from a very weird part of the deep South, I don't believe the male organ is ever pronounced /pi:næs/. It's pronounced /pi:nəs/.
- RyanMcGreal 13y agoI'm reminded of the study that found rats will choose heroin over food, over and over again, until they die; and the follow-up study that compared rats kept in isolation (matching the original study) with rats allowed to live more naturally in communities and found that rats living in communities try the heroin but then go back to eating food.
- mathgladiator 13y agoFor the curious, I think this is the study: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park
- RyanMcGreal 13y agoThank you. That's the study.
- peterwwillis 13y agoA friend of mine at hopkins (several, actually) do lab experiments with mice. Recently one experiment a co-worker was doing was continually failing even though it had been proven to work in other cases. Several of the mice tested would behave fine, but one or two were in terrible health and became highly antagonistic. They couldn't figure out why the experiment was failing. My friend took a look at their setup. During the day there was a machine that was turned on next to the unhealthy mice. It vibrated and emanated a faint noise. He told them to turn off the machine. In a week, the mice were back to normal. Nobody had thought about it, but mice are much more sensitive to sound and vibration than humans and it was stressing them out so much they were going crazy. There's probably lots of other things that can be overlooked (like temperature), but it's hard for us to notice because we aren't mice.
- herbig 13y ago"it was stressing them out so much they were going crazy" An interesting theory, but one that they can't really say was the issue without a controlled experiment.
- stephenhuey 13y agoConstruction Noise Decreases Reproductive Efficiency in Mice: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2715925/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2715925/ Noise in a Laboratory Animal Facility from the Human and Mouse Perspectives: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2949429/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2949429/
- herbig 13y agoRight. The point being, if we're talking scientifically here, you can't just say that the machine was the issue and be done with it. What kind of machine was it? Was the machine emitting radiation? Was it emitting light? What time of day was is turned off? What color was it? Could the mice see if from their cage, or was it out of view?
- comicjk 13y agoRichard Feynman wrote about a very similar problem, that rat-maze experiments rarely controlled for the rats' ability to hear differences in the floor. He used it as an example of "Cargo Cult Science" (http://neurotheory.columbia.edu/~ken/cargo_cult.html http://neurotheory.columbia.edu/~ken/cargo_cult.html) - if you aren't rigorous with your assumptions, you are not doing science, and the truth is not going to come.
- VLM 13y agoThermoneutral means zilch energy consumption at basal metabolic rate when motionless in a windless environment. Its a narrow temp range. For bare humans its about 80F which seems warm because we're usually not motionless and usually wear clothes. You can make a joke out of the whole thing in that they're trying to turn the mice into couch potatoes who don't burn a single excess calorie to better match the human couch potatoes. Its not totally ridiculous to think a drug could be developed that would have different effects on human couch potatoes vs the now somewhat unusual athletic humans. We already have identified compounds like that, take all the roids you want, no exercise means no gains. Off the top of my head there's some medications that screw up human thermoregulation, like prevent or reduce sweating, so exercise for someone on those meds equals heatstroke (well, not guaranteed, but close)