8 ms·
it is not sure it is positive. It's certainly very negative. The advantage is you can use things like solar, hydro or geothermal energy to heat the system. E
by dagw 13y ago
it is not sure it is positive.
It's certainly very negative. The advantage is you can use things like solar, hydro or geothermal energy to heat the system. Even turning 1000MW of geothermal energy into only 100MW of crude oil can be worthwhile since you can't run an internal combustion engine on geothermal energy.
- AndrewDucker 13y agoBut is it better than turning that geothermal energy into electricity and transmitting it to a battery in an electric car? Edit: To be clear, I'm not saying there isn't a need for oil. Just wondering what the efficiencies are for each route, and whether this process means that we don't even need electric cars any more (doubtful, but I thought I'd ask)
- brazzy 13y agoYes - if you don't have an electric car. Or if you're somewhere in Siberia at -40 degrees C where a) batteries stop working and b) you're 500km away from a power line.
- icebraining 13y agoIf you don't have an electric car, it's probably cheaper to buy one than to pay for the gas made by this method, no?
- freehunter 13y agoIt's basically time-shifting. Either you can turn this geothermal energy into electricity and have the consumer charge their car at home over a long period of time (hours) or you can turn it into a full tank of gasoline over a long period of time (hours), ship it to the consumer to fill their tank in a short period of time (minutes). Either way, it takes a long time. The difference is the impact to the consumer of converting it to something useful for them (gas), or having them convert it to something useful (a charged battery). The consumer doesn't notice the gasoline taking a long time, to them it takes minutes.
- dagw 13y agoSure, that's better in the few scenarios when it is reasonable to do so. But electric engine technology is still very limited, and we're a long way from replacing all internal combustion engines with electrical. I doubt we'll seeing transatlantic passenger flights in electric airplanes any time soon. The other huge advantage with oil is that it is a very efficient, stable and easy to transport store of energy. Transporting and storing 1MWh worth of energy using batteries is a serious undertaking compared to transporting and storing the equivalent in oil.
- jccooper 13y agoI'm petty sure I'm being pedantic, but to be clear: Electric engines (motors) are great. Highly efficient, simple, powerful, scalable both ways, and reliable. If you've got electricity available and want things to move, they're the way to go. It's the batteries that are sub par, in many ways.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoThat's exactly why diesel locomotives have always been diesel generators connected to massive electric motors; the best of both worlds.
- aaronblohowiak 13y agonot just locomotives. the biggest earth-movers in the world are all electric vehicles powered by onboard generators. http://www.wired.com/autopia/2013/10/worlds-largest-dumptruck/ http://www.wired.com/autopia/2013/10/worlds-largest-dumptruc...
- toomuchtodo 13y agoBecause you know what happens when you try to pass immense torque through a transmission? Bad things. Its why Elon fought for so long for a 2-speed transmission on the Roadster before giving up and opting for a lower top speed. Electric motors have a ridiculous amount of force they can put out. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Roadster#Timeline http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Roadster#Timeline "Subsequent to completion of production car number one at Hethel, the company announced problems with transmission reliability. The development transmission, with first gear enabled to accelerate 0 to 60 mph (0 to 97 km/h) in 4 seconds, was reported to have a life expectancy of as low as only a few thousand miles. Tesla Motors' first two transmission suppliers were unable to produce transmissions, in quantity, that could withstand the gear-shift requirements of the high torque, high rpm electric motor. In December 2007, Tesla Motors announced plans to ship the initial Roadsters with the transmissions locked into second gear to provide 0 to 60 mph (0 to 97 km/h) acceleration in 5.7 seconds. The first production car was not delivered with this interim solution; P1 has both transmission gears enabled. According to the plan, the initial transmissions were to be swapped out under warranty when the finalized transmission, power electronics module (PEM), and cooling system became available. The EPA range of the car was also restated downward from 245 to 221 miles (394 to 356 km). The downward revision was attributed to an error in equipment calibration at the laboratory that conducted the original test" DISCLAIMER: Tesla's final solution was a single-speed gearbox, combined with software and energy management upgrades. The electric motor will now run as high as 14K RPMs to achieve it's 125mph top speed while retaining it's 4 second 0-60 time.
- Symmetry 13y agoThat may work for cars, but not airplanes. And oil is also an important lubricant and plastic feedstock.
- VLM 13y agoAnd a feedstock for herbicides, pesticides, (some) fertilizers, or on a meta level above those, its a feedtock for "human food". Of course you could eat the algae straight, or feed it to hogs and then eat hogs, but variety being the spice of life its a perfectly valid alternative tech to turn sunlight into food.
- chaz 13y agoGasoline has tremendous energy density compared to other forms of storage. If you need that energy to be portable (like in a car or truck), you may still want to use petroleum. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density
- grecy 13y agoRight, but that doesn't mean anything when we're only getting ~16% efficiency in our ICE.
- beat 13y agoIt means a lot. The Tesla Model S (a reasonable sedan) needs 85kwh to reach a 300+ mile range, and the drivetrain is probably about as efficient as electric cars will ever be. So realistically, we need 85-100kwh of power on board a reasonable car. A single gallon of gasoline is ~33kwh of power. At 30mpg (easy for a sedan), 10 gallons (330kwh) is sufficient for a 300 mile range. So the Tesla is ~4 times as energy efficient as internal combustion, and unlikely to get any better.
- farinasa 13y agoGood thing we have been doing better than that for some time now. >The MAN S80ME-C7 low speed diesel engines use 155 grams (5.5 oz) of fuel per kWh for an overall energy conversion efficiency of 54.4% >The efficiency of a combined cycle gas turbine system can exceed 60%. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_engine#Fuel_economy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_engine#Fuel_economy In fact, it's shameful how underutilized diesel engines are in this world. Same with stirling engines.
- VLM 13y agoIf you're allowed any scientific process regardless of engineering challenge and economics, thermally crack the crude down to hydrogen and pure carbon coke deposits, sequester the carbon for carbon credits, and pipe the H2 into fuel cells for near 100% efficiency.
- 13y ago
- Pxtl 13y agoNuclear. You want to generate a lot of heat and you don't have geothermal energy handy, you go nuclear. You could make the whole facility mechanical - the heat from the reactor is used to heat the algae and use steam-driven pumps to create the pressure. Eliminate the electrical middleman.
- blisterpeanuts 13y agoThat's actually a cool idea. A nuclear plant that generates petroleum products! There might be power left over to feed into the grid, too. I'm sure environmentalists would have a field day with this concept.
- VLM 13y agoYou need a fair amount of hydrogen gas to run a hydrocracker, which is basically what this is. Industrially you get the hydrogen from natgas. Yeah yeah you can get methane from the output of a hydrocracker and hydrogen from methan but depending on the process its net overall hydrogen negative (think about it, how are you going to split a long chain hydrocarbon that has two H ends into two little ones thus a net of 4 H ends without a continuous input of hydrogen?) So yeah you're mostly right but never going to get away from maybe 5% to 10% capacity driving steam turbines to electrolyze water and run the (insecure, of course) SCADA and hotel load for the humans running the plant etc. A likely plant would look like two nuke generating plants backing each other up and 18 nukes cooking algae into diesel, roughly.
- philwelch 13y agoForget the energy content; there are already tons of uses for petroleum that don't require burning it for fuel.
- charlieflowers 13y agoWonder if this could be done in space? A few months ago I read about the idea of solar energy being captured in space, and I struggled with the question of how to transport that energy to where we'd like to use it. If the algae could grow in space, and this process could occur in space, then we could wastefully convert solar to oil in space, and spacecraft could use that oil in space. Lot of if's and speculation there, but it's an interesting line of thought.
- VLM 13y agoI think you'll find radiation to be an interesting additional challenge to add to the mix. That and the relative lack of local oxygen. I get what you're saying though, its a heck of a lot more rational to design and airdrop an algae plant on Mars than to expect oil wells to produce on Mars.
- ceejayoz 13y ago> I think you'll find radiation to be an interesting additional challenge to add to the mix. Not as much in near-Earth orbit where we enjoy much of the Earth's magnetic field's protection. Astronauts come back with an elevated risk of cancer but not tremendously so. > That and the relative lack of local oxygen. Grow some photosynthetic algae too, which'll convert sunlight to oxygen.
- sp332 13y agoI can't tell if you're joking, but photosynthesis rearranges carbon dioxide and water into sugars, releasing some of the oxygen from the water molecules.
- VLM 13y agoAnd when you burn the algae sourced synthetic kerosene and algae sourced O2 in your rocket engine (or whatever you're doing with it) you'll run out of water. And its dumb to ship unprocessed water up into space if you can use cheap earth based refineries to ship the same weight of highly refined fuel. Keep those heavy refineries at the bottom of the gravity well unless you have a really good reason to hoist them up. So that was the origin of my idea that this isn't going to scale in space "in general". I'm told Europa has a lot of water, other than the whole lack of sunlight thing, I could see Europa as the "fuel tank of the solar system" in the future. Maybe it could be economically viable to mine comets and turn them into fuel while they're near the sun? Or mine icy asteroids? I think you're going to overall have more trouble finding water in space than energy.
- salient 13y agoSo just get rid of the internal combustion engine...Surely that energy could be used in a more efficient way - such as filling up batteries for electric cars, and then power 10x more electric cars than oil-based cars.
- tim333 13y agoUsing algae to make ethanol seems a much easier way to go and uses little energy eg. algenolbiofuels.com