6 ms·
How much of this is "building an audience" For example Paypal pretending to be legitimate buyers and purchasing eBay goods but only via paypal? Or reddit postin
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
How much of this is "building an audience"
For example Paypal pretending to be legitimate buyers and purchasing eBay goods but only via paypal? Or reddit posting stories and comments under sock puppet accounts?
If this was a clear impersonation of a specific individual then it is a serious fraud (presumably the company expects financial gain). If it is "These guys are amazing - A Fortune 50 CTO" then half of Hollywood does it every day.
I think that morally overdrawn is the natural state of much of the business world - morally bankrupt is rarer.
So for some actual advice - if it was a crime, report it and leave. If you cannot stomach the ethics even if it is not criminal, then prepare a good resignation letter and leave - but I would counsel that in doing so you are setting a tremendously high bar for your future behaviour - which is a good thing but it has implications. I would suggest making a public note on your leaving and reasons maybe on your blog. no point in being ethical if no one notices.
but lastly I would look inside yourself - are there any other reasons why the last three and a half years have upset you? What decisions did you not agree with - what relationships have gone sour? Is this all plain sailing then one horrible fraud? if so it seems out of character for the company? if not then what things have lead to this - for example this sort of behaviour is usually seen under real stress, so why did the company end up not getting the sales last year, what shortcuts in engineering have lead to a lower product, what lack of marketing ab tests lead to lack of a sales pipeline?
This maybe the right wake up call the company needs to turn around - do you want that? Or do you think this is not a wake up call but the last straw?
I am rambling on but I have found many ethical decisions rarely come out of simplicity and rarely have simple resolutions.
good luck
- jpwright 13y ago> no point in being ethical if no one notices. No meaning to ethics if this is your philosophy.
- SamReidHughes 13y ago> No meaning to ethics if this is your philosophy. What's the basis for the belief (you seem to hold) that it's more ethical to silently tolerate unethical practices instead of outing them publicly?
- jaredsohn 13y agoI don't think the GP is saying that; I think the GP is saying that to be ethical you do something that is right regardless of if you get credit for it. And in practice, publicly stating that you turned in your company for something (even if morally right) can hurt you when you apply to other companies since if they learn of it they are likely wondering if you would accuse them of something if you worked there.
- SamReidHughes 13y agoOh, okay. That makes sense if we take that sentence out of context and treat its wording literally, so now I understand what your GP was saying. However, the real meaning of that sentence as used in your GGP is that these so-called "ethical" choices you might make aren't actually ethical if they don't have any impact on the world. That is, leaving a company because it performs unethical behavior does not stop the unethical behavior from continuing, and so your leaving is merely an ethically neutral action (in fact, by remaining silent, you're enabling further unethical behavior).
- toadi 13y agoThis is ethical and that is not ethical doesn't exist as discussion: "ethics does not provide rules like morals but it can be used as a means to determine moral values" The way it should be stated it's against my moral values. Not everyone's moral values are aligned. Thus rendering this discussion unusable for me as I don't know against what moral value we are judging these actions.
- SamReidHughes 13y agoEthical has exactly the same meaning as moral outside of specific contexts.