3 ms·
The U.S. should stop intervening in other people's business, period. Sounds like a great blurb for a breakfast cereal but not much of a policy. How would you h
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
The U.S. should stop intervening in other people's business, period.
Sounds like a great blurb for a breakfast cereal but not much of a policy. How would you handle global trade? Competition between nations for resources? Ideological world-wide battles that run hot or cold, like we had with communism or Nazism? Struggles to control pollution?
It was true 80 years ago but it's even more true today: everything is all mixed up. Americans are everywhere, making deals on everything. People in Indiana sell things to people in China via E-bay (and vice-versa). The world is simply too complex. Everybody's business is ours (and vice-versa). When we quit in Vietnam we left a lot more people to die at the hands of the communists than died during our intervention.
History does not lend itself to slogans.
- TriinT 17y agoThere seems to be a misunderstanding here. We haven't agreed on what we mean by "intervention". When I say that the U.S. should stop intervening in other people's business, I mean that the U.S. should stop planting brutal dictatorships around the world. These may satisfy Washington's interests in the short term, but they're a disaster in the long term. In the 1950s a left-wing government was elected in Iran, and the CIA and the MI6 orchestrated a coupe to depose the democratically elected government and plant a dictatorship. Same happened in Chile in the 1970s. Sure, back then there was a threat of the having the Cold War turning very, very hot indeed, and sometimes pawns have to be sacrificed. But people don't easily forget. This sort of Uncle Sam's "baby-sitting" prevents the people from doing mistakes on their own, and gives them a common enemy, the U.S.. Let them fail on their own. Especially so if their government was democratically elected. There are smarter ways of fighting for resources. I think the 1991 Gulf War was a prime example. Vietnam was an act of insanity that should never be repeated. If you're going to waste an entire generation of American boys and tear the fabric of the American society, the least you should do is make sure the war is worth fighting.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThere's a long thread of conversation here that we can have another day. I'd simply like to point out that you are using quite a bit of hyperbole. The Vietnam War did not "waste an entire generation" -- casualty figures were nowhere near that high. And "tearing the fabric of American society" sounds like something you'd hear in a political rally. American society's fabric -- whatever that means -- is doing just fine. Enough with the naval gazing. When I run into phrases like that, either in other people or my own writing, it's a red flag that there's quite a bit of emotion lurking there somewhere. Just something for you to think about.