3 ms·
"When I do that, I constantly am left with a remainder. If I accept that 1/3=0.3333..., as you're arguing, then the remainder disappears, for unexplained reason
by jerf 17y ago
"When I do that, I constantly am left with a remainder. If I accept that 1/3=0.3333..., as you're arguing, then the remainder disappears, for unexplained reasons."
No, it doesn't. You stopped finitely soon into an infinite process. You apparently didn't take it far enough.
No disrespect intended, but a HN comment is not a place to post a full description of infinity. Hie thee hence to a textbook. And read it like a textbook, not an internet post. You know, where you go over it with a fine-tooth comb looking for opportunities to leap up and call your opponent a Nazi. Yeah, I know that style. Without that, counterarguments are getting mangled on their way into your brain, because you don't actually understand them in Math. That can't be corrected by people batting down various ill-posed English-based objections.
(If it could, I would have seen it happen by now.)
- drcode 17y agoI agree this discussion can't be taken much further on an HN thread for the reasons you give :)