3 ms·
The most intuitive explanation I've read is that if two numbers are distinct, then you can find a real number inbetween them. No such number exists for 0.999...
by scott_s 17y ago
The most intuitive explanation I've read is that if two numbers are distinct, then you can find a real number inbetween them. No such number exists for 0.999... and 1.
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoAs posted below: (1.0+0.99999...)/2
- ErrantX 17y agocan you solve that equation? (the answer is no, again it's proveable but it is beyond me to do so. Someone else will have to jump in)
- frig 17y agoSee, what's so awesome about that answer is it allows the idiocy to keep rolling. Here goes: Proof: assume .9... < 1 (b/c lol I know this); then: X = (1+.9...)/2 => 2X = 1 + .9... => - 2X < 1 + 1 = 2 x 1 (b/c 1 > .9...) - 2 x .9... = .9... + .9... < 2X (b/c .9... < 1) => 2 x .9... < 2X < 2 x 1 => .9... < X < 1 => proof there's a # between .9... and 1, assuming of course .9... < 1. What's cute about this is it's employing a similar conceptual error: the above proof is literally circular -- it's proving something equivalent to '.9... < 1' (that there exists a distinct # between .9... and 1) by assuming '.9... < 1'; it's just different-looking enough to hide the circularity / equivalence if you don't want to see it (the analogy to the 'debate' as to whether .9... == 1 should be apparent).
- scott_s 17y agoThat's the actual meaning of the phrase "begging the question."
- ErrantX 17y agoIndeed - or to put it more simply it's just rearranging the equation, not solving it ;P
- scott_s 17y agoThat's not an equation, it's a number. There's nothing to solve.
- frig 17y agoAnd if you did 'solve' X = (.9... + 1)/2 using the standard 'algorithms' for doing it by hand you will wind up with X = .9... + .0...1 (more on this in a sec); you get there by noticing 1.9... / 2 looks like it ought to be .9..., but "of course" 2 x .9... == .9...8, ergo you can deduce you have .9... + a remainder of .0...1. If you don't believe .0...1 exists (infinite 0s followed by a 1) then this ought to convince you that .9... == 1 (as (x+y)/2 == x => x == y) but since we're (hypothetically) arguing with someone who believes .9... != 1 it's quite plausible that the person is also going to believe in .0...1 existing, also. What I suspect is actually going on (I've also met otherwise-savvy people who will debate this issue also) is that the human numerical-cognition system uses something like a crude form of nonstandard analysis internally; and, under this theory, you see this internal system (and its intuitions) leak out in some people smart enough to get that .9... really does have 'infinitely many' 9s but who also for whatever reason are both undereducated on this point of mathematics and generally self-assured. Briefly: you can extend the real #s with a new entity (call it delta) such that: - delta > 0 - if r is a nonzero # then delta < |r| - (for now) delta^2 = 0 (in effect: delta is an infinitesimal, it's nonzero but smaller than any other positive #, and delta^2 is 0 is mainly an algebraic convenience). Once you've extended things by including delta you can write extended #s in the form r + s x delta (eg: 1 - delta). If we re-define ".9..." to be 1 - delta, then the following all drop out of that: - .9... != 1 (1 - .9... == delta != 0) - .9... < 1, (1 - .9... == delta > 0) - and we even get: (1 + .9...)/2 = 1 - (delta/2) ==> (1 + .9...)/2 > .9... And more generally in my experience most of the spinning-in-circles around people with beliefs about .9... != 1 is that the people who vociferously believe .9... != 1 don't even know about non-standard analysis (or infinitesimals, etc.) and thus can't articulate what their intuition is telling them, but what their intuition is using is basically (a nonrigorous form of) analysis with infinitesimals.
- grk 17y agoYou can only calculate the limit of that, which is: lim (x->1) (1+x)/2 = 1
- slackenerny 17y agoProve please ; ) It may be intuitive in English, just as 1/3 = 0.(3) thing is convincing, but you'll lose your infinit(el)y-hostile audience at a proof.
- pj 17y agoThe answer isn't intuitive in any language other than the language of math. It can be debated, because the solution cannot be seen with the eyes. Even when it is shown, it is not believed. Math is beautiful like that. You have to trust it and you have to trust your teachers.
- slackenerny 17y agoThe answer isn't intuitive in any language other than the language of math Sorry for I might have not expressed myself clearly. "There is no number you can name between these numbers shown in this notation" is in English and appeals to intuition, it does not show that there is indeed no such number. Food for thought: http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2009/05/you_cant_write_that_number_in.php http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2009/05/you_cant_write_that... You have to trust it and you have to trust your teachers. No. Mathematics is a virtue of explanation (i.e. proving). No trust involved.
- pj 17y agoIt doesn't appeal to intuition, because people can reply as people have replied.