8 ms·
Request for Funding OpenBSD Project's Electricity
- dsr_ 13y agoAny clue as to scale? I suspect more businesses might be interested in funding a $5K/year project than a $50K project.
- sliverstorm 13y agoMy main clue so far is how tight-lipped the email is.
- tedunangst 13y agoThe machine room has an air conditioner that runs during the winter in Calgary.
- cperciva 13y agoThat could mean anything from about 5 kW upwards, which I believe is around $3500/year of electricity in Calgary. Can you be a bit more specific?
- tedunangst 13y agoNot really. It's not my department. dsr wanted a clue, that's the best one I've got...
- gonzo 13y agoHere's something from 2006 that quotes Theo saying the bill was around 100 USD/week. http://openbsd.das.ufsc.br/press.html http://openbsd.das.ufsc.br/press.html and something else that says $600/mo: https://forums.freebsd.org/viewtopic.php?t=38488&p=218116 https://forums.freebsd.org/viewtopic.php?t=38488&p=218116
- masklinn 13y agoThis was the scale 4 years ago: http://www.openbsd.org/images/rack2009.jpg http://www.openbsd.org/images/rack2009.jpg
- gonzo 13y agoit's Theo's basement. How much power could there be?
- sheetjs 13y ago> A number of logistical reasons prevents us from moving the machines to another location which might offer space/power for free, Regardless of the scale, I suspect it would be easier for some companies to offer space and power than to pay bills
- nick2021 13y agoIf a number of logistical reasons prevents.. Why not solve those problems instead!!! Hell, you'd probably be better off asking for free server usage somewhere altogether. This email is too vague and everyone is going to reply with why not do this or that.
- ams6110 13y agoIf I were them I'd reach out to .edu organizations. Many of them have huge clusters that have a lot of idle time, or could at least accommodate a daily batch build. Edit: err, never mind. Reading again I see he's looking for someone to pay their electric bill, not host their servers or provide compute resources.
- masklinn 13y agoWhich is likely why he specifically noted that he could/would not move the machines: he knows this and wants to preempt companies offering free power in a separate space.
- gonzo 13y agoand since the current space is Theo's basement...
- zdw 13y agoThere's a picture of the rack from 2009: http://www.openbsd.org/images/rack2009.jpg http://www.openbsd.org/images/rack2009.jpg I think the big reason Theo doesn't want to ship this offsite is that it's a lot of old/esoteric equipment that often times needs physical TLC in order to make it run properly, or has weird boot requirements, interfaces, etc. They still have m68k, VAX, and Alpha boxes that are at a minimum 10 years old, that they build the OS directly on all the time.
- sliverstorm 13y agoThere's also the possibility of critical failure from transport. Old hardware can wind up as a sort of brittle "dead man walking", where even the slightest unpleasantries in a shipping container kill it for good.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 13y agoWow, that's a pretty sketchy looking "machine room". Wires dangling everywhere, and it looks like a tinderbox (cardboard lying around, wooden beams overhead....)
- snogglethorpe 13y agoIt's also very typical for machine rooms in academia in my experience (the MIT AI Lab had one that looked far worse than this, and others in the same building were similar). [Well, minus the wooden beams, but aside from that...] Business are typically a little better (IME), as they tend to have a bit more money, but sometimes barely. Once you get to giant Google-scale outfits, of course, the game changes completely...
- sliverstorm 13y agoLet's not forget, the value of meticulous organization and cable channels and generally creating cable pr0n is related to the number of racks being managed. In this photo... 2 racks.
- yeukhon 13y agoI wonder if they can just approach to Google and ask if they could just donate a couple Compute Engines... but at the same point, why do we need freebds and openbsd? In terms of resource, can't we get merge the two team together?
- erichurkman 13y agoFreeBSD and OpenBSD are different projects, despite having 'BSD' in their names. They share a lot of concepts, and some code, but they do not share some of the same philosophies and goals. It is not like the Debian world, where there are dozens of maintained forks and flavors of Debian. They are fundamentally very different projects and communities.
- asveikau 13y agoThere is a long history involved. You could have looked it up. OpenBSD split from NetBSD in the 90s. FreeBSD is separate from either one. IIRC FreeBSD and NetBSD both have some roots in a project called 386BSD, and before that, some releases from UC Berkeley. In practice, though, even today they tend to share a lot of new code. When one of them gets a good idea it's often ported to the others.
- weland 13y ago> but at the same point, why do we need freebds and openbsd? In terms of resource, can't we get merge the two team together? Are you a project manager?
- yeukhon 13y agoWow, the tone is very harsh here. What's wrong with my suggestion? i honestly don't get all the downvotes here. smh. Even they are two distinct projects by now, there is no need to be harsh and ask if I were a project manager. The Internet is open to people to question.
- dingaling 13y agoit's always good to ask questions. If you're not familiar with the BSD World, what you asked was tantamount to Why can't we merge Gentoo and Ubuntu?' The BSD clans have very different goals and philosophies.
- shin_lao 13y agoWhat is the difference between asking a company to pay for the electric bill and asking for money to pay the bills?
- pedrocr 13y ago>That way the various OpenBSD efforts can be supported, yet written off as an off-site operations cost by such a company. Tax reasons it appears. Maybe they don't have non-profit status and so a donation can't be put in as a cost before tax but an electricity bill can.
- lflux 13y agoThere's OpenBSD Foundation, which is non-profit but not tax-deductible apparently: http://www.openbsdfoundation.org/donations.html http://www.openbsdfoundation.org/donations.html
- cperciva 13y agonon-profit but not tax-deductible FWIW, this is because Canada is far more restrictive than the USA in terms of what constitutes a "charitable purpose". The FreeBSD Foundation would not be able to give charitable-donation tax receipts if it were Canadian either.
- shin_lao 13y agoI'm surprised that giving "free electricity" isn't seen as a donation.
- gonzo 13y agoI sense increasingly shrill sounds emanating from the OpenBSD camp. Monday: Theo De Raadt, complaining about FreeBSD security, after giving commit access to NSA/FBI contractors to install backdoors in OpenBSD back in 2003. http://www.itwire.com/business-it-news/open-source/62641-crypto-freebsd-playing-catch-up-says-de-raadt http://www.itwire.com/business-it-news/open-source/62641-cry... Pull quote: — "Now we all discover that FreeBSD has been doing it wrong. It's not as if they operate in a closed source world, and couldn't have looked at what others did. They must have chosen a few years ago to do this wrong, intentionally. "Perhaps that decision was made by their Californian developers, the ones who work fairly close to that NSA building. — And his presentation from ruBSD 2013 last week (http://tech.yandex.ru/events/yagosti/ruBSD/ http://tech.yandex.ru/events/yagosti/ruBSD/) http://www.openbsd.org/papers/ru13-deraadt/ http://www.openbsd.org/papers/ru13-deraadt/ In which our friend Theo de Raadt talks about measures in OpenBSD that make attackers life harder: memory allocation randomization, W^X pages and stack protectors. Of course it’s served with a side dish of invective at FreeBSD, as the project does not use all his cool stuff, and how could it then claim to be called a secure system, hmm? Dear Theo, Playing the game called 'guess my memory address' with attackers might be fun, but better to actually isolate them via cap_enter(2), and guarantee success rather than attempting to make a successful attack less probable. Security isn't a game. Your friend, FreeBSD After Theo came Henning Brauer speaking about OpenBSD’s variant of pf. Seems they have made yet another syntax change recently, and that pf performance is up, (but no numbers were reported). Since Gleb (who re-engineered pf to be multi-threaded for FreeBSD 10) had presented earlier in the day, with actual results: http://image.slidesharecdn.com/rubsdsmirnov-131214051554-phpapp01/95/slide-61-1024.jpg?cb=1387019979 http://image.slidesharecdn.com/rubsdsmirnov-131214051554-php... Henning was, of course, queried. Gleb reports that Henning responded, "'in FreeBSD pf is faster than in OpenBSD' is actually a lie, and that if you pick a proper uniprocessor hardware you will see, that in OpenBSD pf can forward 3 times more than in FreeBSD." Unfortunately, he didn't give any hint on the model of hardware he used to generate this result, so reproducing his results becomes… difficult. Then yesterday we get the tight-lipped email from asking for someone to pay the power bill for OpenBSD. I hope he doesn’t get someone in trouble for the obvious tax dodge. Someone else pointed out the rack pic from 2009. Note Theo standing in-front of the same rack in the itwire piece above, and the same photo is used in his speaker page for ruBSD (http://tech.yandex.ru/events/yagosti/ruBSD/talks/1487/ http://tech.yandex.ru/events/yagosti/ruBSD/talks/1487/). So I doubt it's changed much in the past 5 years.