3 ms·
You can't breed a banana. The species can't sexually reproduce, so all plants are essentially clones. This makes the production of new breeds very slow (you c
by ajross 13y ago
You can't breed a banana. The species can't sexually reproduce, so all plants are essentially clones. This makes the production of new breeds very slow (you can't cross-breed to isolate desired traits) and means that when a novel disease arrives, no individual plants will have any immunity.
- jurjenh 13y agoThis is incorrect. You can't breed fertile bananas from the Cavendish, but if somebody kept records of how they got there (crossing which cultivar with what) we could do the same today starting with the original cultivars, which most likely are still around somewhere... The problem is finding the cultivars and doing the whole experimental process with specific plants and documenting it... Given that bananas grow fairly quickly it is probably relatively do-able. Just need some land and some volunteers... And flying under the radar of the banana companies :)
- ajross 13y agoI guess that gets to the semantics of what a "banana" is. You can't breed the plant that produces the fruit we buy in stores. Clearly there are ancestors that could reproduce. Yes, it might be possible to recover most of the traits of a commercial banana by breeding them. But it's never been done, so I don't see where the "This is incorrect" bit comes from.
- maxerickson 13y agoBananas in general are not sterile. The Cavendish cultivar is. The hard part of making new breeds is getting one that is resistant and would probably be accepted at market while not having an overwhelming number of seeds in the fruit (those last two bits overlap a bit).
- ars 13y ago> You can't breed a banana. Sure you can. Only 15% of bananas grown for food are the sterile cavendish type. There are many many other types.
- HNJohnC 13y agoYou most certainly can unless you are a greedy, lazy producer who can't be bothered to do the same time consuming painstaking breeding and selection that has gone on for centuries with other more common crops and simply picks one and clones the hell out of it globally almost certainly ensuring that it's going to meet something that will kill it off entirely due to the lack of genetic diversity. Few things on earth are as weak and helpless as a cloned monocrop.