4 ms·
Move Silicon Valley: America needs a tech hub in a place where it’s welcome
- cmwelsh 13y agoHow come the United States has never seen a planned metropolis, built on the principles of maximum security and maximum density? I know many people who would give up their "freedom" for the ability to live affordably in an environment like that. Where is our Silicon Arcology? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arcology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arcology
- beachstartup 13y ago> planned metropolis, built on the principles of maximum security and maximum density this is exactly what new york is. it was a military base in a protected harbor, that turned into a planned city after several changes of ownership (some would say over-planned). that perfect grid system didn't spring forth organically. i would recommend 'new york', the ric burns documentary.
- scarmig 13y agoPlanned metropolises tend to break: cities are complex, emergent structures. Brasilia gets more shit than it deserves, but the planning that went behind it certainly wasn't good for it. Maybe "planning better" or "planning for better things" could work, but its hyper-modern conceit to not consider how it has failed in the past. Or is failing in the present: see the grand, empty cities that the PRC has been building.
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoMany great european cities grew entirely out of deliberate projects. Some noble family would want to harbor a thriving marketplace so they could tax it. American cities did used to be planned. Philadelphia and New York didn't just assemble as grids. It's only in the postwar era suburbia build out that urban planning became haphazard and driven by developers. The idea of a polity building a well planned city from scratch has loads of successful historical precedent.
- snowwrestler 13y agoBecause central planning doesn't work. Ok, it might work if the central planners could accurately predict the future. But they can't, so centrally planned economies and societies tend to fall behind.
- muzz 13y agoAgreed that central planning doesn't work. But somehow pundits like the author think that their second-guessing of markets somehow would.
- angersock 13y agoBasically, because the street finds its own uses for things. Moreover, any place that is planned, instead of evolving organically, tends to be boring as shit to live in--for evidence, consider suburbs. Very planned, very boring.
- wudf 13y agoHaha. I'm about to move from Cleveland to the Valley in a couple months for the scene.
- exelius 13y agoI don't disagree with the author's premise; but Cleveland? If you look at the major technology startup hubs around the US (San Francisco, Austin, Boston, NYC, Pittsburgh) the one common factor is that they have major, world-class engineering universities.
- selmnoo 13y agoI agree, Cleveland is a strange choice - for more than a lot of reasons. Personally I'm rooting for any of these cities: Chicago, Austin, Madison, Portland, Seattle or Minneapolis. Austin might be the ideal choice, if only for the big weather factor.
- maxent 13y agoCase Western is in Cleveland and Carnegie Mellon in Pittsburgh is close.
- muzz 13y agoWhy aren't you disagreeing with the premise? Businesses are free to locate themselves as they choose. The fact that one doesn't like the result of market forces doesn't mean that the market is somehow wrong.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Segmentation 13y agoNo ocean. In all the world, the richest and most sought after cities to live in are those with ocean views.
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoI'm surprised I've seen no mention of Tampa/Orlando/Palm Beach. No income tax, pro business government, the locals would not get bent out of shape about "outsiders". Good weather and recreation. Also, the whole gateway to Latin America thing. Orlando might have the best flight connectivity of anywhere in the USA; that's a big reason why all the PGA players live there.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- aiiane 13y agoGood weather except for hurricane season.
- rexreed 13y agoMaryland or Virginia. Yeah, some taxes, but the living costs and wage expectations make up for the taxes.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- chaz 13y agoMore generally, tech workers who enjoy healthy six-figure salaries want to live and raise families in nice places. Even if they don't have ocean views, the SF Bay Area offers excellent beaches, skiing, biking, hiking, sailing, surfing, golf, parks, etc. -- all within ~3 hours' drive and for a good portion of the year. The weather and geography are such an important factors.
- rguzman 13y agoWhat would make google et. al. want to move, though? Is it really feasible for government (local or federal) to give strong enough incentives? Those companies are immensely profitable, so I'd guess it's not easy to bribe them with tax breaks. Furthermore, they care to be able to attract talent AND having a critical mass of talent, moving them all at once would only help with the latter, while they have both in SV.
- sirkneeland 13y ago"so I'd guess it's not easy to bribe them with tax breaks." Especially when they are already paying so little tax to begin with on those profits...
- danjaouen 13y agoIf we have to move Silicon Valley somewhere, my vote would go to Rochester, NY: http://rocwiki.org/ http://rocwiki.org/
- jff 13y agoI was actually thinking that. Plenty of schools there including RIT and U of R, lots of office/warehouse/factory space available, unique local culture, cheap (for now) housing...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- swivelmaster 13y agoIs it really consensus that tech workers in San Francisco have that kind of contempt for folks who make less money? The article assumes that premise based on a few data points, but I don't buy it. And anyway, tech hubs are created based on a very specific set of circumstances that are basically impossible to simulate. What company is going to be the Fairchild Semiconductor of Cleveland?
- brianbarker 13y agoCleveland? SLC has more of an argument. I'd still go with Austin if we had to move it, though.
- VladRussian2 13y agoquick google shows that non-competes are enforceable in OH. Not-starter for hi-tech. TX pretty much the same. For illustration, as another poster mentioned Fairchild - with enforceable non-competes you'll never have the "Fairchild Semiconductor of Cleveland"
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- VladRussian2 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-compete_clause#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-compete_clause#United_State... CA sounds pretty much like an exception. This is why i live here :)
- greenyoda 13y agoJust because a state enforces non-compete contracts doesn't mean that companies have to use them. If a company in Ohio or Texas is trying to convince people to move there from California, and these people refuse to agree to non-compete contracts, the companies will have to stop that nonsense since it will prevent them from hiring the people they need.
- ConnorBoyd 13y agoI'm probably biased, but I think the Denver/Boulder area would be a good candidate
- altoz 13y agoThe author of the article is obviously schilling for Cleveland and other rust belt cities that no longer have the manufacturing jobs that they used to. Cleveland is one of the most heavily regulated and wasteful cities, as is Detroit. I would say that big companies aren't wanted there any more than they are in SF.
- mhurron 13y agoHow about not having one and we can finally have some of these companies offering actual remote work.
- stormcrowsx 13y agoIt's 27 degrees right now in Cleveland, need I say more?
- kps 13y agoGo everywhere and nowhere. Move bits, not bodies.
- mgberlin 13y agoA huge factor that the author fails to account for is weather. Public transit might have it's pitfalls in SF, but there are no snow days. There's no ice on the roads. There's no hurricanes, or tornadoes, or summers that require A/C at all hours. You don't really have to pay to heat your home or office all winter. You can drive to the snow if you want to ski, or you can hang out on the beach in January. The Bay Area is a paradise, meteorologically speaking. It's the reason that people who live on the street congregate here, and it's the same reason people are willing to pay exorbitant rent. There are very few other places in the country that even come close to competing, and it's not something that even the likes of Google can take with them to Cleveland.
- muzz 13y agoThe biggest factor that the author fails to account for is the market. Businesses are profit maximizers. They locate themselves where they can profit the most.
- arbuge 13y ago"What’s needed is for a critical mass—say Google and Apple and Facebook and Twitter—to move all at once, to the same place, thus immediately creating a new tech hub." Most of the millionaires who cashed out of those companies have already left, and many others would be unwilling to relocate. I don't think moving the ecosystem of angel investors etc. which powers the valley is so easy.
- mwnz 13y agoThis whole idea that you can simply define an equivalent tech hub is misguided. Like it or not, there is nowhere in the world that compares to silicone valley. This, despite the high land prices, poor public transport and high rental prices.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sirkneeland 13y agoParis has strict rules on how tall a building can be within the city core. That certainly puts a dent in any plans to increase the density of the city...
- dynofuz 13y agoMiami anyone?
- michaelochurch 13y agoI don't think this will happen. Large tech companies have offices in the rest of the country, but getting the best projects and the promotions usually requires being at HQ. If you're serious about Google, you'll work in MTV. If you're serious about working for Goldman, you want New York. Sure, you can work in Madison or Austin and be employed by a Silicon Valley company, but you'll be getting the projects that the mother ship passed on. If you want to live in Austin, then you're best off working in an Austin company if you want a career there. Nor are VCs going to move just to "spread the wealth" geographically. They're rich enough that this rent shit isn't their problem and they're settled. Whatever is to reverse this condensation of tech in the Bay Area is going to be post-VC; someone will have to figure out how to target and structure the mid-risk/mid-growth (15-40%/year growth) businesses that VCs hate. I have ideas on structure: http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2013/03/26/gervais-macleod-17-building-the-future-and-financing-lifestyle-businesses/ http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2013/03/26/gervais-macle... It is a nice idea, and if technology comes through with a post-VC wave (a return to maker culture) we will see that geographical shift. It won't be "a new hub". It'll probably be 20 or so microhubs, of which San Francisco and New York will be included. I could see a strong forecast for: Austin, Boulder, Durham, Baltimore, Portland. Boston is well-poised to make a comeback, and Chicago could show some strength.
- gmays 13y agoCome on down to San Diego, we'd love to have you.
- intangible 13y agoWhat's wrong with Vegas? There's plenty of room here, Project 100 and other interesting tech companies starting up, and close enough to fly in or drive to and from the Valley if needed every so often. Also, the city is trying to diversify from just Casino culture as it is, so you can get a decent amount of support for pie-in-the sky projects, not to mention the business-friendly tax laws.
- koberstein 13y agoI vote Reno. The real estate market is cheap. It is just a few hours down the 80 from the bay. Tahoe is our neighbor. The city is motivated to attract tech.
- bobosha 13y agoWhat about Seattle?