3 ms·
but does that mean we should treat gang-related graffiti intended to intimidate the same way we treat some dumb suburban kids playing a prank? Same property da
by mindcrime 13y ago
but does that mean we should treat gang-related graffiti intended to intimidate the same way we treat some dumb suburban kids playing a prank?
Same property damage, same punishment, IMO. "Justice is blind" and all that jazz...
On the other hand, this shit isn't all theoretical and academic, and life isn't all about idealism.
What is life "about" then? Do you have any principles, or is it just "let me get mine and f%#@ everybody else"?
I have a wife and a kid and we live here and sometimes walk home from work late at night, and I'm not going to complain if the police crack some heads in the process of keeping the gang violence to a low simmer.
Easy to say when it's not your head being cracked.
I think this makes me less morally culpable than the other middle/upper class people ...
I'd tell you what I think it makes you, but it would probably get me banned from HN.
- rayiner 13y ago> Same property damage, same punishment, IMO. "Justice is blind" and all that jazz... Justice is a solution to a problem, not an end in itself. "Kids are marking up property as a prank" and "kids are marking up property to demarcate gang territory and intimidate people" are two different problems that are only superficially related, and warrant two different solutions. > What is life "about" then? Do you have any principles, or is it just "let me get mine and f%#@ everybody else"? Safer cities don't just benefit me, but the vast majority of people who live in them. I think the right of that majority to live free from insecurity and the collateral damage of gang violence is a bigger concern than the rights of individuals. > Easy to say when it's not your head being cracked. Sure, but that's easy to flip around too. It's easy to wax philosophical about policing methods when you're not the one getting mugged, you're not the one afraid to walk home at night, etc. It's easy to talk academically about the civil rights of flash mobbers when they beat and rob people on a different street than the one your girlfriend uses to walk home late at night. Most people I've met who actually live in New York, Chicago, in the city proper, have a more pragmatic view of policing methods than people who would have to get in their car and drive to see a poor person.
- mindcrime 13y agoI think the right of that majority to live free from insecurity and the collateral damage of gang violence is a bigger concern than the rights of individuals. And this is why we will probably never agree on anything. :-) As far as I'm concerned, the rights of individuals are far more important than "the right of the majority to ..."