5 ms·
As I see it, the authors must retain all their copyrights, because any valid transfer of copyright would entail valuable consideration from Elsevier to the auth
by logfromblammo 13y ago
As I see it, the authors must retain all their copyrights, because any valid transfer of copyright would entail valuable consideration from Elsevier to the author. The authors pay Elsevier to coordinate peer review and publish using their brand names. This necessarily includes granting a license to Elsevier to copy and distribute the author's work.
Now, there may be other contract terms that are not obvious. One such term may be that the author not publish the work himself. The worst that could happen here is breach of contract. Since the only up-front consideration was from the author, this just means that Elsevier doesn't need to do what the author paid them to do, while still keeping the consideration of cash plus copyright license. It's sole remedy is to not coordinate peer review and not publish. Since it ALSO charges fees on that end, it has no reason to do that.
There must be a quid pro quo in a lawful contract. You can't bind someone to its terms unless you give them some valuable thing in return. Elsevier gives NOTHING to the author except the promise of publication and distribution. You can never prevent the author from making his own copies, ever. Your sole remedy is to write a penalty for doing so into the contract, but then you would have to PAY the author something to enforce it.
Elsevier does not give the authors anything, therefore they cannot demand performance under the contract. The only thing they can do is use one of those restrictive terms to weasel out of their own obligations under the contract while still keeping what the author gave them. They are absolutely in the wrong by demanding people take down their own work.
(I am not a lawyer.)
- simonster 13y agoAs ridiculous as it sounds, many journals, including Elsevier journals, require you to transfer copyright of your article to them. See http://cdn.elsevier.com/promis_misc/phcgj_copyright_form.pdf http://cdn.elsevier.com/promis_misc/phcgj_copyright_form.pdf for one example.
- logfromblammo 13y agoThat's ridiculous. It's not even funny. I can't imagine how such a contract could stand up in court if contested, unless Elsevier actually paid the owner of the copyright something. If a contract does not involve an exchange of value between the parties, but instead appears to be a one-sided transfer, a judge might strike it down as unconscionable. If the contract were voided in this way, instead of breached, Elsevier would have to give back everything it got from the author. If you paid for it, even one penny, that sale is much easier to defend in court. But they don't pay. They charge at both ends.
- gngeal 13y agoThat's ridiculous. It's not even funny. It's also null and void in my country (.cz), and probably in many other European countries.
- jahewson 13y agoI highly doubt it, the Czech Republic signed the Berne Convention along with the rest of Europe.
- gngeal 13y agoWhat has the Berne Convention have to do with it? I've compared the Elsevier contract draft with my local legislation, and the wording of the contract is simply unenforceable.
- anigbrowl 13y agoTreaties have the force of law, which is why they're such important documents. Your local law does not apply to materials originating outside of that jurisdiction.
- fphhotchips 13y agoYou seem very knowledgeable, so let me only add what I know to be true: this is location and context dependent. For example: If I make a contract with another Australian (company, individual, whatever), no treaty has an effect on that contract unless legislation has been passed to enact that treaty. A judge may refer to the treaty if there is some ambiguity that requires his/her discretion, but the treaty itself is not legally binding.
- anigbrowl 13y agoQuite. But if you make a contract with me (in the US) you wouldn't be able to blow it off under cover of Australian law, is what I mean. So if Elsevier's contract terms are legal in their (Elsevier's) domicile, people who enter into contracts with them need to keep that in mind - which is why most contracts have a 'choice of law' provision saying which laws will govern the enforcability of the contract in the event of a subsequent dispute.
- jahewson 13y agoYeah, it's excessive, do they really need the TV rights?
- ggchappell 13y ago> ... many journals, ... require you to transfer copyright of your article to them. Nearly all of them, in my experience.
- jahewson 13y agoNo, the contract is "considered", as the authors get peer reviewed and published by a big brand name and the publisher gets to charge the readers - everybody gains something valuable. What you refer to as "contract terms" are mostly part of copyright law and nothing to do with this specific contract, for example the copyright holder has "the exclusive right to produce copies or reproductions of the work and to sell those copies" under copyright law which means that it is quite natural to transfer that exclusive right to a publisher thus preventing the author from making their own public copies. There is usually a contract term permitting authors to engage in ad-hoc sharing with colleagues for this reason. Likewise there is usually a contract term allowing authors to post their work to public-facing institutional/departmental web servers. (The original article linked to doesn't specify exactly what material was posted, I would speculate that somebody posted a bibliography or some other collection of papers in which they are not an author, and that is why the publisher is unhappy). The publisher unquestionably delivers value to the author, their academic career rests on the value embodied in their peer review process and a typical article costs over $1000 to publish. There's certainly a conversation to be had about Elsevier and their policies but it does not include the phrase "Elsevier doesn't give the author anything", which defies logic.
- ggchappell 13y ago> The authors pay Elsevier to coordinate peer review and publish using their brand names. Traditional academic journals do not require payment from the author. While author-pays journals are becoming more common, AFAIK all journals published by Elsevier still work the old way. Elsevier makes money off its journals through subscription fees.