3 ms·
> Accuracy is not what is required, given our extremely poor and fuzzy knowledge of the human body, diagnosis and treatment is more like a tradeoff between diff
by baddox 13y ago
> Accuracy is not what is required, given our extremely poor and fuzzy knowledge of the human body, diagnosis and treatment is more like a tradeoff between different possibilities based on partial symptoms (not all symptoms will be obvious or noticed by the patient), tests which are not always accurate and sometimes harmful, and treatments which are not always effective and have some bad side effects.
I don't understand. That scenario is a perfect example of something an expert system would excel at.
- grey-area 13y agoNot really no. Some steps are suitable for codification in an expert system, indeed doctors already use expert systems in some cases. Some things which are hard problems and are not currently solved better by expert systems: Translating what the patient thinks is happening into a set of symptoms, sometimes those two are far apart Finding problems the patient came in for but is too embarrassed to talk about or is even unaware of Explaining risk to patients in terms they will understand, and then choosing an appropriate treatment based on their often fuzzy and emotional response Weighing patient risk against an individual patient's needs or other ailments which an expert system is not going to be able to query about or be aware of. etc. There's certainly a huge and growing place for expert systems in healthcare, but suggesting they can replace doctors is pretty absurd at this point in time.