4 ms·
> The rich pay less because they spend less as a proportion of their income than the middle classes. Yes but this is already happening right? Isn't it far easi
by chaostheory 13y ago
> The rich pay less because they spend less as a proportion of their income than the middle classes.
Yes but this is already happening right? Isn't it far easier for them to keep lobbying for new tax loopholes as older ones get closed, than it is to avoid a flat tax? Am I missing something?
> The poor pay less because they are given exemptions, or a pay boost equivalent to the tax they pay.
I've never heard about this. Can you give more details?
- Nursie 13y ago>> Yes but this is already happening right? Not to the extent it would under "Fair Tax", no. >> Isn't it far easier for them to keep lobbying for new tax loopholes as older ones get closed, than it is to avoid a flat tax? Am I missing something? It makes it far easier for far more people at the higher end of the income scale to pay a lot less tax and codifies regressive taxation as the intent of law. Make no mistake, the people who came up with the scheme would not be supporting it if they didn't stand to benefit from it, significantly. It puts their 'loophole' way out front and legitimises it. >> I've never heard about this. Can you give more details? Fundamental to the scheme is that the poor would get some sort of tax credit, possibly an annual payment, in order to offset the new sales tax, where previously they would have paid little to no income tax. This is not the part of the scheme I object to. The re-balancing of burden onto the middle classes, and in a way that affects those with lower incomes more than higher incomes, is why I think the scheme is a failure from its very conception. You may have the kind of economic ethics that support a tax that declines as a percentage of income as income rises, or even argue that all people should pay the same lump sum in tax, that's up to you. Personally I can't get behind that.
- chaostheory 13y ago> Not to the extent it would under "Fair Tax", no. Ok what percentage of their income do they pay now compared to what they would pay under Fair Tax? What percentage of income do middle class households pay before and after a Fair Tax? > It puts their 'loophole' way out front and legitimises it. Yes but what happens when the government decides to increase the flat tax?
- Nursie 13y ago>> Ok what percentage of their income do they pay now compared to what they would pay under Fair Tax? This is pretty irrelevant as we agree they're dodging now, and the Fair Tax would encode that as the law. Better to attempt to close the loopholes or imagine a third system than to move to a system that's regressive by design. As for the general rule - the proposal requires a roughly 30% national sales tax. If I earn more then I spend less as a proportion of my earnings (this is a recorded economic phenomenon, not posturing), therefore my Fair Tax percentage is lower than people who earn less, even within similar socio-economic strata. I'm not sure there's anything hard to understand here. >> Yes but what happens when the government decides to increase the flat tax? Not sure what you're driving at with this question. The obvious answer is "everyone pays more". --edit-- If you don't think those on high incomes should pay the same or higher percentage of their income as those on lower earnings, that's a different argument entirely. I'm arguing that given the position that those on higher incomes should pay the same percentage or higher in tax as those on lower incomes Fair Tax is a bad idea. If your politics don't match to this assumption then you might as well say because we're not going to come to any sort of agreement!
- chaostheory 13y ago> This is pretty irrelevant as we agree they're dodging now I would strongly disagree. Conservative estimates say the wealthy pay an 18% tax rate. Less conservative estimates put it at around 10-11%. It does matter. It's a lot easier to lobby for new loopholes when everything is less transparent. What FairTax does is make things more transparent than they were before. > Not sure what you're driving at with this question. The obvious answer is "everyone pays more". Yes... including the extremely wealthy. It's very difficult to lobby for new loopholes against something is that is really easy to understand. > If you don't think those on high incomes should pay the same or higher percentage of their income as those on lower earnings, I agree with you. They should pay more. However I strongly disagree just going down the same path of closing loop holes. It doesn't work. The middle class isn't smart enough as a whole to organize and hire lobbyists. I'm just being realistic with what's possible before I get ancient.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Yes but this is already happening right? Isn't it far easier for them to keep lobbying for new tax loopholes as older ones get closed, than it is to avoid a flat tax? The point-in-time adoption of a flat tax doesn't make it harder for them to lobby for tax loopholes after that adoption than it was before that adoption. You can't compare flat tax to the status quo tax system on the assumption that in the former system the rich will magically lose their ability to lobby for changes to the existing tax code when nothing in the change proposed does anything to make that happen.
- chaostheory 13y agoI'm just guessing that it'll be much harder for them to lobby when the issue is more transparent and easier to grasp, as oppose to thousands of complicated laws where only tax lawyers and accountants can truly see the big picture. What we have now doesn't work. What makes you think going down the same path will magically fix things?