3 ms·
It's a misogynous analogy. If we call it out we can make the world a better place, where everyone is actually equal and break the horrible let's-pretend-we're-e
by onion2k 13y ago
It's a misogynous analogy. If we call it out we can make the world a better place, where everyone is actually equal and break the horrible let's-pretend-we're-equal-while-holding-some-people-down status quo. Everyone's a winner. Except misogynists.
- waterlion 13y agoHear hear. But you're not doing it properly. Please be consistent. "what about being human when it matters most? In person" - doesn't this exclude people with social anxiety disorders? "mix of knock-off stilettos" - doesn't this exclude people who wear flats? "people bumbling about who looks a hair too much like Dwight Schrute" - doesn't this exclude people who do look like him and may have body image issues? "You have just entered the land of networking hell" - this imagery is deeply offensive to some religions "Screw the schmoozing" - using sexual imagery? No thanks. "The people who hand out business cards like they are condoms in a high school sex ed. class" - alienates those with a conservative upbringing "Disclaimer – keep those condoms, kids" - again, pretty offensive to Catholics "They want meaningful relationships" - again social anxiety "And people respond to kindness." - not everyone. Exclusionary to those on certain parts of the autistic spectrum. "The same philosophy goes for networking" - I can imagine quite a few real philosophers getting offended about the belittling of their profession "One good conversation is better than five quick ones every day of the week" - not the Shabbat! "It’s for people who will never be more than middlemen" - think of all the middlemen out there, feeling excluded at this hate speech and switching off "when you remember to be human" - deeply insulting to robots
- johnchristopher 13y agoAh yes, the wonderful binary world of computer people where nuances only come in the form of 0 or 1.
- waterlion 13y agoSorry, I should have put a <rhetoricalIllustration> tag around that to clarify that I don't actually believe any of the above. (Do I really need to say that?). I won't spell it out again, I've made other comments in this thread.
- VLM 13y ago"where everyone is actually equal" The point of the article was making fun of a small subgroup of humanity who like meatspace networking events in a format similar to cosmo-style psuedo-risque dating advice. And some folks don't like his use of an analogy of exhibitionistic-ish women. The problem is if you stick to a dating advice theme, what analogy would you prefer? White men can't jump would be much more politically correct because they're a politically safe target, but doesn't fit the theme at all. Also the theme of "lets make fun of suboptimal behavior of a subgroup" is completely incompatible with your proposed "lets pretend we're equal" theme, so the article not fitting your criteria is the opposite of a fail, under the defined theme and purpose of this individual article, however good it might be as general life advice. So either its a great analogy for this specific text, or its a horrible text so the specifics of the analogies and other details don't matter. But it can't be both at the same time such as a bad analogy.
- jmduke 13y agoIn this case, it's likely worth pointing out that the author is female.
- moogleii 13y agoDefinitely. Misogyny is thrown around so much now that it's getting a bit absurd. She made a quip about push up bras => MISOGYNY! If I made a quip about dudes padding their underwear, what would that be? And I've always thought of misogyny to mean the hate/dislike of women; in other words, a perpetual and sustained belief, but these days it seems to be attributed to singular insults/moments of disrespect. The two are related, and hate may imply disrespect but a moment of disrespect does not imply hate.
- MartinCron 13y agoWomen can and do use misogynistic, inappropriate, and unprofessional language, too. The "was that really necessary?" question is still perfectly valid to ask even when the author is female.