2 ms·
I find your argument, which is based on what the government compels others to do, to be oddly limited. You often focus on the phone call aspect of a phone, and
by dalke 13y ago
I find your argument, which is based on what the government compels others to do, to be oddly limited. You often focus on the phone call aspect of a phone, and compare it to a 1970s pen register. But that doesn't fit with modern phones.
An SMS message, or a smart phone check for new messages or to get map data, would under the 1970s technology parallel be implemented as a phone call. Under your logic, law enforcement would get all this information as well, no?
If so, most smart phones positively leak information. (Note that according to Judge Leon's opinion, it's not known if the metadata we're talking about includes data related to text messages. See p52, footnote 56.
If not, why not?
Also, the current system captures more information than a 1970s pen register. As footnote 57 points out, the pen register in the 1970s Smith decision did not keep track of if the phone call went through, nor the length of the call. It then points out the difference between building location from the 1970s, and caller location from mobile phones, with reference to New Jersey vs. Earls. 'the New Jersey high court found that "cell-phone location information, which users must provide to receive service, can reveal a great deal of personal information about an individual."'
So at least in New Jersey there is a distinction between the two.
The point in Judge Leon's opinion is that "This rapid and monumental shift towards a cellphone-centric culture means that the metadata from each person's phone "reflects a wealth of detail about her ... associations" ... that could not have been gleaned from a data collection in 1979." (page 54).
While you are entitled to your beliefs, I would enjoy it if you compared your beliefs to the actual opinion under discussion.
- Aloha 13y agoI should point out, the original post I meade that spawned this rather large thread, had no bearing on the decision - it was my opinion purely. Something else I should point out - there were mobile (pre-cellular) phones in the 1970's and some geolocation data could be implied from their use - because in most cases they couldn't roam beyond their home area. For what its worth, some of this data could have been gathered as early as 1979 - when the first AMPS systems were being turned up. Beyond that - I guess what I'm looking to say is, landline equivalence, I don't think you should be able to collect more information about a mobile phone user than a landline one, even if the information is there - at least not without a warrant. My discussion here has really been about what is acceptable without probable cause and a warrant, and not just for the NSA - but for all Law Enforcement Agencies. I think Call Detail Records and Call Associated Geolocation Data is acceptable, but really, nothing else, not without probable cause and a warrant, I even think that using big data techniques on CDR's is novel and worthwhile - but it should be as a clue to find more information thru old fashioned police work, not as the end evidence.
- dalke 13y agoYes, I do believe I understand your argument. My question to you is three-fold: 1) the judge gives 10 pages of opinion, with 4 distinct points, on why land-line equivalency cannot be used as a guide. Can you speak to why you disagree with those 4 points? 2) Do SMS and app data count as "telephone calls"? Does an open TCP socket, which isn't in use, count as a "telephone call"? Under a landline equivalency doctrine, your answers must be yes. In that case, if most people's phones check for messages automatically every 5 minutes, then is there really that much of a difference than what we have now? Will your view change in the future when peoples' phones connect every minute, or have a continuous connection? Also, since you mentioned the start of this rather large thread, there's another point. You said "I'm somewhat OK with big data being used in this case, these are cases that traditional police work cannot be used in" Judge Leon pointed out that the government has provided no evidence that "big data" was used to solve any case, and that a government witness has stated that most of the times other methods could be used, only that metadata gathering is faster and cheaper. 3) Given that, how do you draw your opinion that traditional police work cannot be used in this case, when the government themselves cannot convince the judge?