3 ms·
I see you are an attorney, so I'll skip the detailed explanation of vertical stare decisis and simply point out that Sotomayor joined Scalia's opinion in Jones,
by bradleyjg 13y ago
I see you are an attorney, so I'll skip the detailed explanation of vertical stare decisis and simply point out that Sotomayor joined Scalia's opinion in Jones, which commanded a majority and was the opinion of the Court. Therefore, the holding of the case has to do with the continuing validity of traditional trespass as a fourth amendment search, and the mosaic theory in the concurrence is dicta. I personally find it compelling, but I'm not a District Court judge bound by the strictures of precedent.
Nothing in Smith itself or it's Supreme Court progeny indicate that the length of time the government intends to keep information that it found the people have no reasonable expectation of privacy in is of constitutional moment. Nor the number of phones, or how frequently they are used. As for SMS and writing letters, it is the Court's allowing the government to collect mail metadata (the envelope info) that got this entire line of precedents started.
If this had been an email case, I'd be right there with you. I don't think the device that the government wanted to install in the Lavabit case is sufficiently similar to a classic pen register to be covered by Smith, and I think the third party and his representations matter with respect to customers' expectations. But here we have telephone records as collected by telephone companies. Smith is squarely on point. Limiting Smith to 1979 is tantamount to overruling it, not distinguishing it.
Judge Leon doesn't like Smith, I get that, I don't either. Fortunately or unfortunately, neither if us is on the Supreme Court. (See also, Reinhardt, J. any opinion.)
- thucydides 13y agoIt's possible to distinguish Smith as inapposite without throwing away stare decisis. The term of surveillance (forever), the breadth of surveillance (almost every American), and the greater privacy intrusion (because of cell phones' ubiquity and because we use them more frequently) all make NSA surveillance very different from Smith. And as far as the length of surveillance goes, Kerr's pointed out that 5 justices in Jones (the 2012 GPS case) signed onto the idea that long-term GPS monitoring of a car counts as a search even if short-term monitoring does not.