4 ms·
I hear people saying that medicine can't have doctors be replaced by computers and it's more of an art than a science. I'd like to get more information and see
by EGreg 13y ago
I hear people saying that medicine can't have doctors be replaced by computers and it's more of an art than a science. I'd like to get more information and see why they think that and if their reasons really hold up. It intuitively seems to me computers can do a better job. Here are a few reasons:
1) When you think about what a doctor does, they use a combination of their memory, experience, knowledge and judgment.
2) Computers can remember a lot more relevant facts and wonmt forget them.
3) A doctor's experience is just with their own patients and what they hear at conferences and the literature they read. A computer network can literally aggregate experiences of many different doctors and cases around the world. A new superbug coming out, for instance, may have a treatment that few doctors know, because it's more prevalent in another country -- but a person using the network will be made aware of this treatment. The network will have much more experience than an individual. It will aggregate the outcomes of many therapies and studies.
4) The knowledge of the network can be extracted from the experiene and be much more extensive. Both beause the experence is extensive and because various methods of statistical analysis can be employed. A doctor isn't going to sit there and cross reference worldwide statistics on the success of using remedy X given factors of race, gender, age, etc. The computers can.
5) Finally, the judgment. Here is why the computers can beat a doctor's "gut" overall. They can cross correlate the knowledge from all around the world and find the most major factors. Then given the symptoms, race, age, location, etc. they can suggest the possible diagnoses given realtime epidemiological statistics and the additional tests that need to be done to establish which diagnosis is most probable. In many cases this establish a path to just one diagnosis with statistical accuracy exceeding what one doctor can produce. It can also list the next several possible diagnoses and the tests to establish them. After the diagnosis is established, it can find the therapies along with risk factors gleaned from all the relevant outcomes from around the world.
And this is just for conventional medicine. When we get into genetic therapies, computers and information science will become a huge part of medicine.
- zarify 13y agoI tend to agree about the accuracy of diagnoses when the data is good. Here's the 'but': I think my main reason for distrusting computer diagnosis is that computers are still pretty terrible at figuring out what we are telling them, and patients are also pretty terrible at describing what symptoms they're suffering from. It's all very well to aim a camera at some sort of visible symptom, but what happens when there's nothing there to match against a library of exemplars? (For comedic value, the data entry panel from the hospital in Idiocracy: https://s3.amazonaws.com/lardbiscuit/pix/idiothospital.jpg https://s3.amazonaws.com/lardbiscuit/pix/idiothospital.jpg )
- EGreg 13y agoOf course we will still need a doctor to perform the tests. But they'll be relying much more on the apps to suggest to them what tests to perform next. The patients won't be telling the computer anything, esp the unconscious patients, and photos won't be analyzed by computers. Idiocracy was a cool movie :)
- Dewie 13y agoI think I read a short snippet about introducing a new IT system in a doctors office. The doctors were against having to do things in a new way due to the new system, even though it probably was more efficient. I think the reason or theory behind their reluctance was that it would automate some of their regular duties. I can imagine that many doctors will not feel kindly about working with a system whose purpose is to automate (some) of their work, and which gets smarter and more independent the more the doctor works with it.
- zarify 13y agoTo be flippant it's starting to sound like you're describing the canned question list in a call center :) The computer analysis of photos was actually something I thought was quite positive. I believe they've been doing this for skin cancer for a while (based on what my mother, who worked in a skin clinic for a few years described to me, before she escaped to do GP work again).
- bigchewy 13y agoYou've hit a minor portion of what a doctor actually does, the differential diagnosis. At my last business (in sleep medicine), we learned that our patients who met their long term respiratory therapist (RT) before their differential diagnosis had a 20% higher adherence rate than patients who met their RT afterwards. Concentrating on the Dx is a common desire of the bay area crowd but the reality is we value human relationships. A computer with the best differential diagnosis capabilities will under perform a reasonably competent doctor with empathy simply because patients are more likely to adhere to the prescribed treatment regimen. now, augmenting doctors with additional information is a different story. I've spent the last 10 years of my life working on that problem.
- PavlovsCat 13y ago> the reality is we value human relationships that reminds me of this: We don’t utilize EMR at the Surgery Center of Oklahoma. Partly due to patient confidentiality concerns. Partly because every operating room I’ve ever been in that has computer capability results in a nurse with her back to the surgeon and patient, typing constantly. Not good patient care, in my humble opinion. http://032a410.netsolhost.com/WordPress/?p=275 http://032a410.netsolhost.com/WordPress/?p=275
- vacri 13y agoThere's factors you're completely missing. One of the things doctors do is ferret out information that the patient doesn't volunteer - they socially manage the patient to divulge information. Until we have diagnostic computers that can pick up on non-verbal cues and other such nuances, we'll have doctors.
- ghshephard 13y agoOn the flip side - I'm a helluva lot more comfortable divulging sensitive information to an expert system than I ever would to a doctor.
- dagw 13y agoI think we need two classes of doctors. One that is a diagnostics and medical computer systems experts and never actually meets patients and one who's main focus is human and social skills that actually talks to patients, gets the data to feed into the computers and then interprets and explains the results.