2 ms·
I suspect the courts would agree that actual public things, like a twitter stream or publicly published photos, can be viewed and recorded without a warrant. An
by jrochkind1 13y ago
I suspect the courts would agree that actual public things, like a twitter stream or publicly published photos, can be viewed and recorded without a warrant. And I would agree with you that that is right and proper.
I find your 'non-invasive' category to be odd though. I am not sure there is any legal basis for 'non-invasive' having any bearing on these issues, nor do I think it ought to. Recording the full contents of all your phone calls would be just as 'non-invasive' as recording the 'metadata' -- it would not 'disrupt the target' in any case. I don't see what 'non-invasive' has got to do with it.
- dkokelley 13y agoFrom a legal perspective, I don't know if non-invasive data collection falls under a certain category. I know that authorities cannot enter my home and bug it or install cameras without a warrant. Authorities cannot install a camera in my bathroom to see if I am flushing away drugs, but can they ASK the water company to tap my pipe as it returns to wastewater management? The first action would require a warrant, since they are violating my home and person to obtain the information. If the same or comparable data are gathered through the cooperation of a third party, does that action still require a warrant? I suppose the standard of 'non-invasive' is whether information is collected directly from my non-public activities (warrant certainly required) or from compliant third parties. Of course if the third party does not cooperate then a warrant will compel their cooperation. I would argue that ANY data collection on a target should require a warrant issued by a judge for probable cause. So, indiscriminate collection of cell phone metadata would be prohibited, because my metadata is included, and there is no probable cause for surveillance against me.