5 ms·
Your previous point: > If your definition of morality is "a system for decreeing who should die" rather than "a system for ensuring everyone lives", you are th
by tokenizer 13y ago
Your previous point:
> If your definition of morality is "a system for decreeing who should die" rather than "a system for ensuring everyone lives", you are the problem.
Isn't correct. No individualist chooses anything for anyone else less it be voluntary and without force/coercion.
> Justify your religious faith using objective data and control groups, or go back to church, please.
Resorting to name calling isn't going to win you any awards. I'm an atheist and I just simple believe freedom comes at a cost of having to have individual responsibility in terms of sustaining your welfare and direction. I come from a multi-generational welfare home. The state pacified my family, it didn't help them. I broke the cycle through individual merit and determination. This would still allow you to do as you wish, so long as others volunteer for your collective, and you don't infringe on an individuals rights.
My system permits yours to exist. Does yours permit mine to exist? That's the real moral crossroads we sit at. Also:
> Justify your religious faith using objective data and control groups
You know Philosophy isn't science right? The fact you ask for it screams you're a utopian statist who simply wants to be god. What is your alternative to individual freedom? A complex set of fluidly changing social rules that bind/limit us all that go beyond violence? Jail or Injure a Man/Woman because they disagree to cooperate with your rules? Just don't harm or tell me what to do and we'll be friends. Sounds like that's not reciprocal with you, and that I'd be required to follow other rules, lest I be jailed/killed/banished/boycotted.
Also, it seems like any anarchist society not predicated on either individualist or consensus based policy is prone to majority rule. What do you do with opposition? Punish them? Even if they're non violent. This all screams government, which ruins the anarchy...