3 ms·
Point (a) isn't sufficient to understand the 4th amendment. For example, the Supreme Court in Kyllo vs. U.S. decided that using a thermal imaging device to sca
by dalke 13y ago
Point (a) isn't sufficient to understand the 4th amendment.
For example, the Supreme Court in Kyllo vs. U.S. decided that using a thermal imaging device to scan houses to find indoor marijuana farms is an unreasonable search, and reversed Kyllo's conviction for growing 100 marijuana plants.
You'll easily note that scanning a house from the street does not inconvenience the person being searched, take up their time, or involve a degree of forced submission.
For another example, the Supreme Court said that attaching a tracking device to a car without a warrant is also an illegal search. This also does not fit the criteria of (a). (While it immeasurably slightly worsens mileage, the court decided that it was a form of trespass. One does not need to be present in order for trespass to occur.)
For a more historical example, Ex Parte Jackson (1878) says "Letters and sealed packages subject to letter postage in the mail can be opened and examined only under like warrant, issued upon similar oath or affirmation, particularly describing the thing to be seized, as is required when papers are subjected to search in one's own household. The constitutional guaranty of the right of the people to be secure in their papers against unreasonable searches and seizures extends to their papers, thus closed against inspection, wherever they may be."
Again, 4th Amendment protection of letters exists even when the conditions of (a) are not held.
- Aloha 13y agoThis is the same reason I find disclosure of geolocation data collected outside a call without a warrant to be an unreasonable search.
- dalke 13y agoCould you be more explicit on which reason is this "same reason"? I listed several reasons. Do you think law enforcement use of E911 pings without a warrant is trespass on your possessions, which was the reasoning behind the US vs Jones (2012) case I mentioned? In any case, United States v. Graham disagrees with you. Geolocation data is "information voluntarily disclosed to a third party" and so "ceases to enjoy Fourth Amendment protection." What do you find wrong with the reasoning in the Graham ruling? In reviewing your other comments, it sounds like you also disagree with the conclusions of pages 47-56 of this most recent opinion by Judge Leon, where the judge describes how collection now is different than from a few decades ago, and in a manner that the Supreme Court has indicated other cases indicated may have substantial 4th amendment concerns. Why specifically do you disagree with the reasoning behind his opinions? Obviously US v. Graham (US District Court for Maryland) and Leon's opinion (US District Court for DC) are at odds. Leon points that out in his own opinion, on p66. It's going to take the Supreme Court (or a big change in the law) to sort this one out for the US.
- Aloha 13y agoI would argue that the e911 data is not a voluntary disclosure. The cellular companies were compelled to generate and provide this information, as well as generate and store hordes of other information to assist law enforcement. In short, I don't think the government should be able to compel a company to store a class of data about its users, then because now they are holding it (at the behest of the government), then strip the data of privacy and compel the cellular companies to provide it to law enforcement. I don't find a substantial difference between the police planting a tracking device on your vehicle, and requesting geolocation data records for your mobile phone, they achieve largely same goals, thru only what I consider marginally different means - meaning, both should require a warrant. The exception to that would be geolocation data that is generated as part of making a phone call. I want to hold the line on what can be monitored to the era before always on mobile communications devices. Just because the data is there, does not mean it should be able to be gotten without a warrant.
- bmelton 13y agoi think I find your reasoning flawed, as a matter of personal opinion at least. > Who you called, who called you, how long you talked - this stuff, which is otherwise known as call detail records it available to nearly everyone who works for the telco and is not really what I would consider private. I see what you're saying, as applied by the Smith v MD, that the information in a PEN register is fair game, but even in Smith, the collection of records had to be manual, which prevented its collection and use en masse, meaning that its application was self-limiting. Sure, the police could probably collect all the PEN registers, but as most of it would be useless, why would they? Regarding your earlier statement though, for some perspective, had the British been able to keep tabs on the metadata of the populace, our founding fathers would have all been hanged for treason, and America would never have declared independence. I don't mean to suggest that being subjects of Britain would be necessarily bad, but I think it's fair to suggest that our founding fathers considered their actions just, and as a matter of course, would have likely considered actions that would have resulted in their death equally unjust. If you agree, I think that should have some bearing on your interpretation of the fourth amendment.