2 ms·
There's a copy at http://legaltimes.typepad.com/files/obamansa.pdf http://legaltimes.typepad.com/files/obamansa.pdf . The opinion says i) the NSA program const
by dalke 13y ago
There's a copy at http://legaltimes.typepad.com/files/obamansa.pdf http://legaltimes.typepad.com/files/obamansa.pdf .
The opinion says i) the NSA program constitutes a search under the 4th, and cannot be compared to Smith v. Maryland, along with four different reasons for why they are not comparable, and ii) there's significant likelihood that the search is unreasonable.
The judge points out that while "reasonable" is in general individual in character, the Supreme Court does allow a few exceptions. For example, parolees may be searched to see if they are following the terms of their probation even if there is no individual suspicion.
The opinion then looks to see if the government's claims fit that "patchwork" of exceptions. The judge writes "Given the limited record before me at this point in the litigation - most notably, the utter lack of evidence that a terrorist attack has ever been prevented because searching the NSA database was faster than other investigative tactics - I have serious doubts about the efficacy of the metadata collection program as a means of conducting time-sensitive investigations in cases involving imminent threats of terrorism."
Don't apply your contrapositive logic to that statement. It still doesn't mean that the NSA program, had it been effective, would be constitutional. The opinion points to the government statement that the government could use other means with fewer 4th Amendment problems in order to get the plaintiff's telephone metadata. Had the NSA data gathering been effective, the judge could still have decided that the "plaintiffs have a substantial likelihood of showing that their privacy interests outweigh the Government's interest in collecting and analyzing telephony metadata and therefore the NSA's bulk collection program is indeed an unreasonable search under the Fourth Amendment."