3 ms·
Just because the third-party doctrine has always been applied to phone records, doesn't mean they were not protected. The court just decided they weren't. The T
by rhizome 13y ago
Just because the third-party doctrine has always been applied to phone records, doesn't mean they were not protected. The court just decided they weren't. The TPD is not law.
- rayiner 13y agoI'm normally amenable to the "just because the Supreme Court says so doesn't mean they're right" line of argument, but in this case not as much. The 4th amendment prohibits "unreasonable" searches and seizures. The word "reasonable" has an important significance, one of which the founders (being mostly lawyers in the Anglo tradition) were aware. When the standard for something is "reasonableness" that essentially commits to the judiciary the task of drawing lines on a case-by-case basis and developing doctrines to guide that task. In other words, what the Supreme Court says about the 4th amendment has particular relevance because the wording of the Constitution commits to the judiciary, in a special way, the task of determining the scope of the 4th amendment.
- rhizome 13y agoOf course, but by the same token it doesn't make sense to say phone metadata was previously protected nor unprotected. It was just an early point (cf. CFAA) at which the gov't made a case that they should never be blocked from getting this information whenever they want, for any reason. Likewise, "reasonable" is really putting lipstick on the pig, since there was really no previous history of use for the data, aside from phone companies keeping it away from law enforcement as a matter of business. Furthermore, as far as the TPD goes, there is no "case by case" basis once the judiciary says, "if the person gives it to a business, it's yours."