2 ms·
(c), I feel, matches the original problem best when taken to an increasing number of doors, but makes for an absurd game show. It also most closely resembles th
by Jtsummers 13y ago
(c), I feel, matches the original problem best when taken to an increasing number of doors, but makes for an absurd game show. It also most closely resembles the odds of the original game show (win by switching (n-1) of n times, or 2 of 3 with 3 doors). Anything else becomes a different game (you don't have a single choice, you have a multitude of choices). And it doesn't turn it into a different problem, it exagerates the odds of the original problem to better illustrate the statistics to people whose intuition is wrong. The case of 100 doors where switching results in winning 99% of the time gets passed the questioners intuition that it should be even odds (switching or staying).
(a) demonstrates that the questioners intuition about the probabilities is off, but (again, IMO) doesn't really offer the clarity of (c).
Re: Summary - I agree, it's not an accident. It was chosen because it was a good number for a game show, and leaving the participant with 2 options (switch or stay) ensures a certain swiftness of decision. While (a) (say they used 4 or 5 doors) offers only a slight improvement on the odds (contestants may lose too often) and (c) (again with 4 or 5 doors) offers a perhaps too great improvement of the odds (contestants win too much if they know the trick).