2 ms·
Crunched the numbers, I'm wrong. If the host shows a goat (when the host doesn't know where the car is), switch or stay doesn't matter as you have the same odds
by Jtsummers 13y ago
Crunched the numbers, I'm wrong. If the host shows a goat (when the host doesn't know where the car is), switch or stay doesn't matter as you have the same odds either way.
There are 4 outcomes to the selection phase of this game:
1/3 - both pick goats
1/3 - you pick the goat, host picks the car
1/3 - you pick the car, host picks the goat
0 - you pick the car, host picks the car
So given the host picks a goat, switching or staying doesn't matter it's 50/50.
EDIT: An aside - why we shouldn't trust our intuitions, but instead actually work out these problems.
- jiggy2011 13y agoYou're right. When doors are opened randomly you can not tell whether the host was "lucky" (to not reveal the car) or whether you picked the right door to begin with since these are both equally likely.