7 ms·
To put it mildly this is the first step in a long, long path. District courts have the final say in the vast bulk of routine matters that never get appealed, a
by bradleyjg 13y ago
To put it mildly this is the first step in a long, long path.
District courts have the final say in the vast bulk of routine matters that never get appealed, and they can play an influential role in setting the presumptive factual record in high profile cases destined for appeal. But in a high profile case destined for appeal that largely turns on interpreting the Constitution, this court was mostly a gatekeeper. In other words, if the district court had ruled the other way, maybe that would have been the end of the story. Given that it ruled as it did, this will certainly be heard by the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia (possibly by one of the judges appointed by Obama now that the filibuster has been weakened), and then if the petitioner wins there, either by the full DC Court of Appeals en banc, or the Supreme Court, or first one then the other. If Smith v. Maryland is to be overturned, it will be the Supreme Court that does it, not a district court.
Still, I wish the plaintiffs the best of luck.
For further analysis keep on eye on fourth amendment guru Orin Kerr. His first post describing the opinion is already up: http://www.volokh.com/2013/12/16/judge-leon-enjoins-nsa-telephony-metadata-program-larry-klayman-lawsuit/ http://www.volokh.com/2013/12/16/judge-leon-enjoins-nsa-tele... and he says another with analysis will be coming soon.
- declan 13y agobradleyjg: I generally agree except that "if the district court had ruled the other way, maybe that would have been the end of the story." This was a case that would have been appealed no matter who won and who lost. Still, the factual record established by the judge (who indicated he was annoyed at misrepresentations by NSA/FedGov) is going to help the plaintiffs quite a bit after FedGov appeals. Also, I wonder if Orin read the opinion fully. His post incorrectly says: "Finding the entire NSA metadata program unconstitutional, Judge Leon enjoins it..." That is not true. The judge's opinion did not halt the NSA phone metadata program overall; it merely orders two plaintiffs removed from the NSA's database. I posted about that important distinction here: https://twitter.com/declanm/status/412697277363286016 https://twitter.com/declanm/status/412697277363286016
- mpyne 13y agoWell in fairness to Orin, that was what all the reporting seemed to say, was that the entire program had been summarily ruled unconstitutional (but that the ruling was stayed).
- declan 13y agoOrin's blog post linked to the full text of the opinion (http://www.volokh.com/2013/12/16/judge-leon-enjoins-nsa-telephony-metadata-program-larry-klayman-lawsuit/ http://www.volokh.com/2013/12/16/judge-leon-enjoins-nsa-tele...) and quoted from it. He wasn't merely summarizing news articles. Orin is a smart fellow, and it's common to make mistakes when quickly summarizing court opinions that have just been published. But he never corrected his post.
- thucydides 13y ago> If Smith v. Maryland is to be overturned... The Supreme Court wouldn't necessarily be deciding whether Smith v. Maryland should be overturned, but whether NSA collection of phone/SMS metadata can be distinguished from Smith. The district judge here presents some excellent arguments that Smith is fundamentally different, and I was disappointed to read Professor Kerr's very sloppy analysis, given how excellent his Fourth Amendment coverage usually is. Perhaps he did not have a chance to read the case carefully. Brief background on Smith v. Maryland: In Smith, a robbery victim complained to police that she was continually receiving threatening and obscene phone calls. The phone company installed a pen register at police request, without a warrant or court order, to record metadata for about 2 weeks; this revealed the phone numbers of all subsequent callers to her home. It also revealed that Smith made another harassing phone call. In short, the Supreme Court ruled that, in the process of calling, Smith voluntarily transmitted the phone numbers he dialed to the phone company, information he and everyone else know are commonly stored as business records, so he had no reasonable expectation of privacy in the numbers dialed. Therefore, the Fourth Amendment didn't apply. Contrary to Professor Kerr's blog post, the real reasons Judge Leon thinks the NSA's metadata collection is different are quite compelling. Here's my summary of his reasons from pages 42-56: 1. Smith surveillance was only for 2 weeks; NSA surveillance is for as long as terrorism lasts in the United States (forever?) 2. Previous case law supports a distinction on the basis of time length: In US v. Knotts (1983), the Court said police use of a tracking beeper on an automobile does not implicate the Fourth Amendment because we have no reasonable expectation of privacy in our movement on public streets. But last year in US v. Jones, the Court distinguished Knotts, which was about short-term tracking, saying that police installation of a GPS device on Jones's car for a month was too long and violated Jones's reasonable expectation of privacy. 3. In Smith there was no indication the phone records would be kept; NSA keeps phone records for 5 years 4. Smith was a one-time, targeted request; the NSA program is a daily, all-encompassing, indiscriminate dump of phone metadata. Leon: "It's one thing to say people expect phone companies to occasionally provide information to law enforcement; it is quite another to suggest that our citizens expect all phone companies to operate...a joint intelligence-gathering operation with the Government." 5. The Smith Court did not foresee in 1979 the "almost-Orwellian technology" the NSA is using to track and store hundreds of millions of Americans' phone data. 6. "Most importantly," the nature of the information in our telephony metadata is much different. 7. Phones are ubiquitous and much more frequently used, so metadata reveals more about our private lives and implicates a bigger privacy interest than in 1979. 8. SMS metadata reveals who we wrote to, information that would not have been available in 1979 phone metadata when we had to write letters. Judge Leon's conclusion, which I think is compelling given the foregoing: "I cannot navigate these uncharted Fourth Amendment waters using as my North Star a case that predates the rise of cell phones."