5 ms·
From the article: "The judge, Richard Leon of U.S. District Court in Washington, said that the NSA relied on 'almost-Orwellian technology' that would have been
by wpietri 13y ago
From the article: "The judge, Richard Leon of U.S. District Court in Washington, said that the NSA relied on 'almost-Orwellian technology' that would have been unimaginable a generation ago, at the time of a landmark Supreme Court decision on phone records."
I disagree strongly! The NSA's technology would more properly be called super-Orwellian. Two-way TV, hidden microphones, and steaming open your mail is nothing compared with what the NSA can do.
- salient 13y agoI was just thinking today - we're about to start using "smart light-bulbs" in a few years. Lightbulbs with Internet connections, that can potentially record everything we say anywhere, even in real world (unless they are doing that already with idle cellphones). If we don't stop this now, and don't make it explicitly illegal, and actually punish the people involved (otherwise they's no downside to continuing it), then it will get a lot worse in the future. Also, how can US law be so asymmetrical? It's illegal to look into someone's mail, which just includes one single conversation, but it's not to look at someone's real-time conversations for a long time, which can include all sorts of topics, and then multiply that by millions of people. If looking into just one mail conversation is illegal, how come mass surveillance isn't immediately seen as massively illegal?
- pwnna 13y agoBecause these laws are made a very long time ago and it takes time for them to catch up with reality.
- pyre 13y agoThe government's position is that collecting the data isn't surveillance until a government employee actually looks at the data. E.g. the idea is that you collect a huge pool of data, and then get individual warrants to go spelunking in it.
- daenz 13y ago> and then get individual warrants to go spelunking in it. And that warrant is obtained whenever, in the future, that that person opposes the national interests. Then it's like you've been spying on them all along. Retroactive wiretapping!
- rhizome 13y agoMcCarthy and Hoover's wildest dreams realized.
- pyre 13y agoDon't knock McCarthy. If it wasn't for him then China wouldn't be on the Moon!
- bayesianhorse 13y agoHow do you know China actually landed on the moon? (Just kidding...)
- ihsw 13y agoIf hundreds of thousands of letters stream in and out of the US every second then you bet your ASCIIs the government wouldn't waste time "modernizing" the law to be more "aligned with international norms."
- ENGNR 13y agoI think Orwellian surveillance was a degree worse because you could never escape it. Even in your most private spaces you had to act as if everything was ok, and the body lead the mind into thinking everything was ok. Not that I'm defending current practices, but if we ever get to mandatory mass surveillance it will definitely be worse than covert mass surveillance that the most informed citizens can still choose to avoid.
- dreamfactory 13y agosince we all started walking around with internet-connected mobile devices with a ton of hardware sensors this got a lot trickier.
- declan 13y agoAnd let's not forget about FedGov reportedly activating laptop cameras without the indicator lights turning on (presumably microphones too): http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/2013/12/06/352ba174-5397-11e3-9e2c-e1d01116fd98_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/2013/12/06...
- scarmig 13y agoBy being able to "choose to avoid," what do you mean? Simply that anyone can avoid surveillance by choosing not to communicate over phone, email, or http, and by not living in communities that directly or indirectly pass any of your information over any of those? With 1984, at least, the book implies that the proles had some measure of freedom from surveillance (though the plot also suggests that it's still there but more surreptitious). Short of living on a commune and totally removing yourself from the broader economy, what can people actually do to avoid NSA surveillance as it exists today, let alone a decade from now?
- praxulus 13y ago>phone, email, or http It's pretty easy for any two informed citizens to avoid those means of communication. When you're corresponding with someone who doesn't care if the government spies on them, no level of paranoia will keep your messages private.