4 ms·
You realize that the fiction of a coherent "Military Industrial Complex" has been debunked several times right? One by the General Accounting Office showed that
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
You realize that the fiction of a coherent "Military Industrial Complex" has been debunked several times right? One by the General Accounting Office showed that military contractors actually had higher profits in peacetime than wartime because they got money for 'research' and didn't have to actually produce any product.
- d23 13y agoNo, I didn't realize that. But if you have some credible sources, I'd love to read it.
- diydsp 13y agoIt doesn't require coherent, self-identification to exist. It doesn't need to make more profits during wartime than in peacetime to exist. It only needs to have multiple actors whose interests align to produce more military funding and hardware than is needed to defend the nation.
- typon 13y agoThat sounds extremely unlikely. Most research projects don't get hundreds of millions of dollars of funding, while a single F-22 costs upwards of $150 million.
- nekopa 13y agoThe total program cost of the F22 is $66 billion. On a Pentagon spending request site they put the per unit cost as $354 million if you include R&D and procurement costs. So maybe it's more likely than you might think.
- wutbrodo 13y agoNot that I necessarily buy in to the idea of "a coherent Military-Industrial Complex", but this doesn't really debunk much. It seems to me that peacetime profits for military contractors are dependent on the assumption that there's going to be wartime usage of the research they're doing in the short- to medium-term. Surely if we went a significant period without any military engagements, there would be far less of a push to fund the research of military contractors (I know that military research tends to make it into the consumer sphere and make us all better off, but that's definitely not what motivates the funding).
- EpicEng 13y agoExcept we don't live in that fantasy world. In reality there always is, and always has been, war looming on the horizon. Maybe we'll someday achieve a utopian, Star Trek like existence, but I don't imagine it will be anytime soon.
- lolbertarian 13y agoThat's cute that you think there is an inherent existential threat imposed by the rest of the world that wasn't deliberately exacerbated by those interests who stand to profit from such conflict.
- EpicEng 13y agoWell I'm flattered that you think I'm cute, but I'm not sure where you pulled any of the other nonsense you wrote from (I have an idea). I never made any of the arguments that you claim I have. If you read the parent, he doesn't buy the debunking of the industrial military complex because, in a theoretical world where war is not a common occurrence, the conclusion doesn't hold water. Well, that's nice, but in the real world, war happens. A lot. It always has and it still does. The reason for this is irrelevant. You talk about war being manufactured for personal gain (with no proof I would add, but whatever). True or not, it's irrelevant. We're talking about human nature here. Do you really think a time will come in which everyone is moral and good and wars cease to occur? If you do then you believe that we will somehow alter whatever it is that brings people like this into existence. I hope you're right, but for now you're living in a fairy tale. I prefer to deal with reality as it is, not what I wish it were.
- vdaniuk 13y agoUS doesn't have a looking war on its horizon. I will be happy to hear arguments if you don't agree.
- EpicEng 13y agoIt's not a matter of knowing that a specific war is coming, it's a matter of preparing for what may come. Wars (or, at least, situations which require military intervention) happen all of the time. As such, we will always be preparing for the next one. The point is that humans are always fighting with one another. Until that stops there will always be a war looming.
- samstave 13y agoDebunked by whom? You know what would help "debunk" such a thing; if there was a site where every single investment made by any member of congress was required to be listed.
- samstave 13y agoNot too much peacetime going on: http://i.imgur.com/Mwe1jxG.jpg http://i.imgur.com/Mwe1jxG.jpg
- baddox 13y agoI wonder then, what is your explanation of why the US military behaves the way it does?
- AmVess 13y agoOne does not need to be at war in order to be a MIC.
- rdtsc 13y agoI didn't say it is coherent. Systems sometimes seem coherent, which feeds simplistic conspiracy theories (also serve as a straw man counter-argument). In reality complex systems are decentralized but often are evolving according to some rules. Those rules make it seem as it is a coherent large system. Think of an ant hill, a beehive, how large organizations are structured bureaucratically. Chomsky, for example, analyses this in respect to the media. Large media ends up acting in sync with government's propaganda because there are set of constraints and incentive s built in. From outside they often act _as if_ they are centrally controlled by a single government party.
- aagha 13y agoIn aggregate (military contractors) sure, but there's no doubt individuals who benefit more during war time than peacetime.