3 ms·
From what I recall, there's a big counter-argument to this, which is that management is necessary because organization is fundamentally necessary, and that when
by crazygringo 13y ago
From what I recall, there's a big counter-argument to this, which is that management is necessary because organization is fundamentally necessary, and that when there are no formal "managers", certain people wind up being informal managers, but because this is "hidden", it winds up being less accountable, more open to cliquishness and/or discrimination, and having a host of problems of its own.
I've been trying to find an article I remember which describes how this is particularly bad for women, who can easily be "informally" excluded, but I can't find it... All I can find is this, on Valve:
http://www.pcgamer.com/2013/07/08/valves-flat-structure-contains-hidden-layer-of-powerful-management-claims-ex-employee/ http://www.pcgamer.com/2013/07/08/valves-flat-structure-cont...
- amirmc 13y agoI think the article you're referring to is called The Tyranny of Structurelessness. Article: http://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm http://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm Wikipedia page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tyranny_of_Structurelessness http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tyranny_of_Structurelessnes...
- ep103 13y agoThis is a wonderful article, and details quite nicely why you can't simply throw managerial theory out the window and pretend everything will be okay. It goes into depth about the problems one encounters if an organization attempts to eschew all management, and then goes into depth about how to fix these issues while maintaining a flat organization (in short, just because you acknowledge that a managerial position exists does not mean that that position needs to hold asymmetric power over the people who are managed, as occurs in the traditional hierarchical model).
- amirmc 13y agoIndeed. Doing away with the 'formal' structure doesn't mean the function of that structure also goes away (if that makes sense). This is true for many things e.g even if you don't have a sales team in your company you still have a sales function. Superficially getting rid of something (say, 'management') instead of dealing with the specific problems (e.g. miscommunication, poor incentives, opaque decision-making etc) doesn't seem like a long term solution, though it may be very satisfying for a couple of years. Something I found ironic when I read that article is that it (very nicely) articulated things I've known since school, just by observing social interactions. I suspect most people also know these things but they get forgotten as we grow up.
- chaz 13y agoWhen Ryan Carson's post made the rounds here not too long ago, I was really surprised by what got them thinking about removing their managers. http://ryancarson.com/post/61562761297/no-managers-why-we-removed-bosses-at-treehouse http://ryancarson.com/post/61562761297/no-managers-why-we-re... By 2013 we had grown to 60 people with seven managers and four executives. As we added more people to the team, we noticed something disconcerting: rumors, politics and complaints started appearing. If you have more than two people in an organization of any kind (company, sports team, high school, PTA), you're going to have all of those things, and it has nothing to do with good or bad management. They seem pretty happy with their decision to have changed their structure, but if they think that the rumors, back channeling, and quiet lobbying are gone, I think they're going to be disappointed.
- Shivetya 13y agoI don't believe having managers is bad, I believe in having too many is what really causes issues. I have seem some organization charts where managers managed a single person and they themselves might be the only report to another. Its like the title is giving out in lieu of compensation or to not hurt someone's feelings. Worse is assigning people to someone just because their a manager regardless of the assigned person's work.
- r00fus 13y agoSo what is the ideal proportion of managers to workers - and do you count a manager who gets his/her hands dirty to be a worker or manager?
- ep103 13y agoSo I spent some time in anarchist circles, and what you've just described comes up regularly. It can actually be even worse than what you just described, specifically because the informal managers are also not given the social status a formal manager is. That means that in worst case scenarios and poorly working teams, they are expected to both keep up the workload of the position they officially hold, while also keeping up the managerial position (burnout), or alternatively they are regularly challenged as to the validity of their managerial knowledge. That said, in rapidly changing situations, that second component is actually a great strength, as it ensures a free market of ideas within the potential "manager" pool, and allows an organization extremely rapid ability to respond to change. And so long as there is some intra-team awareness and team focus on measurable goals, the former can be placated as well. There is another weakness, in situations where the managerial overhead is extremely intensive, unchanging and time consuming, ie, when the situation results in people who informally spend all of their time doing management, simply because it is more efficient for one person to do it, than that burden to be shared on everyone. The positive to this is because the position is informal, the number of people working on it will be exactly proportional to the amount of work required to be done, while in a normal organization there is a drive to increase management as much as is sustainable by the organization, both as employees attempt to gain higher salaries, and individuals already in management attempt to retain theirs. The negative is that as the informal position moves between individuals willing to put in the time to do the work, if there is no process to track who has done what, accountability can be an issue. To attack this accountability issue, the traditional anarchist response has always been to formally recognize these positions, and work hard to ensure that these people are replaced regularly by democratic process. Someone below linked the tyranny of structure-less management article, which goes into far more depth, and arrives at the previous sentence as its main conclusion. In our modern software startups, these are exactly the situations we attempt to automate, so it is less of an issue. So now we are left with an issue of the size of the organization which wants to attempt this managerial structure. In small groups, such stringent processes as just described need not be defined. If you have a decently working team, this is how people coordinate by default nature, and this informal position will move between people as different individuals show initiative. A simple system of ledger books or signing line on various forms will likely be sufficient to keep organized most tasks undertaken informally. If these positions are not acknowledged, it begins to break down once you reach teams where members are counted in 3 digits, hundreds or several hundreds, simply because now you have to recognize that individuals do not work in groups of such size. So really, you are working with a large group of groups, and the dynamics change quickly. Unfortunately, I cannot comment on how this works in reality. In modern America, by the time a group grows to this size, it is considered a political threat, and ripe for extrajudicial dismemberment by the state. I do not know how it would act in the comparatively safe environment of corporate organization, though I imagine most of the problems could be alleviated by automation and programming, such as a good CMS system, but I have no experience there.