3 ms·
If I were asked for a GPA or an SAT score at any job interview, I would walk as well. It's completely irrelevant, and highly dependent on the school you went to
by freehunter 13y ago
If I were asked for a GPA or an SAT score at any job interview, I would walk as well. It's completely irrelevant, and highly dependent on the school you went to (is a 4.0 at DeVry better or worse than a 3.0 from CMU?)
It sounds like you're a little older than a person who would be debating going to college, though. I had a coworker that trained me at my current job who only had a few classes at a community college. Being hired a decade after him, it was required that I have a bachelors degree. Things have changes rapidly in the past few decades in terms of HR expectations at larger companies. I'm not trying to detract from your advice, because I think you're absolutely correct. I'm just wondering if you would be able to replicate your success today.
- tptacek 13y agoMaybe it's hard to get a job at Google without a degree (at least, if you're not a software security person). Don't work at Google. There's an industry full of small software startups and an open war for talent right now; start your career at one of the shops smart enough not to pay attention to college records. For every successfully-executed role in your resume, it becomes progressively more and more insane to screen you out based on your degree. Since the starting state on screening by degree is already "pretty crazy", it doesn't take long to make college irrelevant. But again, to make that work, you need to be serious enough about your craft that you can demonstrate ability clearly.
- VLM 13y ago"If I were asked for a GPA or an SAT score at any job interview, I would walk as well. It's completely irrelevant," Its highly relevant if they're going for the stealth ageism thing. GPA is an age proxy. Due to grade inflation, the "respectable" GPA I earned in the 80s would in the 10s mean I was at least highly unmotivated if not outright mentally impaired. There was a time, a long time ago, when mid three something was a respectable accomplishment. Superficially, if you ask an accountant job applicant how much their first car cost, after getting their first real job, that sounds wise. After all, the more expensive, the better they must have been at budgeting and money management, or at least they were ambitious when filling out loan paperwork, and that sounds like a great skills for an accountant. However obviously due to inflation all it will do is prioritize cheap young meat ahead of older more expensive. My great grandfather's first postwar 1946-ish caddy was only about $3K, therefore by numerical metric definition he'd be only 1/10th the accountant compared to a 2013 grad buying a modern commuter car.
- russell_h 13y agoOne thing I would add to that, before walking away talk to the hiring manager about it. HR is just following some set of guidelines, and in many cases a good manager can work with them to make the problem go away. Think of it as a test for your prospective manager as much as anything else.