3 ms·
How I Passed My U.S. Citizenship Test: By Keeping the Right Answers to Myself
- pgsandstrom 13y agoThe questions accepting both the correct answer and the slighly incorrect answer I can understand. The "rule of law"-question, however, seemed more serious. I really wonder how things like that come to be.
- jrockway 13y agoI'm guessing the test was not written by a lawyer, is how.
- gtCameron 13y agoNot only that, but its not intended to be answered by lawyers either. For a bar exam that question wouldn't be a good one, for a test to see if someone grasps the general concepts of how America works, it seems perfectly reasonable.
- TallGuyShort 13y agoWhen I took my test, most of the people in the waiting room were struggling with basic English. They tested my ability to write English by asking me to write the phrase, "The US flag has 50 stripes", but I got it wrong because I wrote "fifty" instead of using Arabic numerals, and they awkwardly discussed whether or not to tell me my mistake and ask me to redo it, or fail me. They tested my ability to read by showing me three similar sentences, reading one aloud, and having me point at the one they had read. The test questions and answers are published online for the same types of people who might be challenged by these questions: people who haven't patiently gone through the whole process. None of it really assesses your ability to communicate in America or participate in the democratic process. This article feels like picking at the unlikelihood of the legal situation in Dr. Doolittle. "Animals have been talking this whole time..." -- Josh Sneed.
- TallGuyShort 13y agoedit: I believe the phrase would have been "50 stars", not "50 stripes". THAT would be a flagrant error in the test :)
- rm999 13y ago>Why does the flag have 13 stripes? The official answer: "because there were 13 original colonies." In fact, the flag has 13 stripes for the 13 original states. Maybe I misunderstand the point, but Delaware was the first state to be granted statehood in 1787, a full 10 years after the "Betsy Ross" flag with 13 stripes was in use. If you're going to write a super-pedantic article, you should be super-accurate too.
- 5555624 13y agoIn that case, though, the "Betsy Ross" flag was not the United States flag, since they were not states. Anyway, when the number of stripes was set at 13, it could very well be because of the 13 original states. After all, it was replacing a flag with 15 stripes. (When Vermont and Kentucky became states, both stars and stripes were added, so the flag -- of "Star Spangled Banner" fame --had 15 stripes.)
- Sae5waip 13y ago"a tremendous honor" -- wait, what? Why should becoming a citizen of a country be "an honour"? (Especially when the country in question is the US; it fits the "US americans are superior humans" theme just right, even when realistically it doesn't seem to be something to be proud of... but that's besides the point.)
- astrodust 13y agoBecoming a citizen of any country, be it Canada, Australia or Iceland, is an honour. The only reason you go through this painful process is because you want it.
- TallGuyShort 13y agoI don't agree with the "superior humans" side of thing at all, but there are an awful lot of people at these ceremonies who didn't just up an decide to come to the US, but fled here due to serious problems in their home country, often of a political nature. They've spent a huge chunk of their lives just trying to get the right to stay here permanently. It sure feels like an honor, even if it only took you so long because of a broken immigration system, and even if the US has a lot of political problems of its own. edit: For instance, the country my family is from denied us the ability to return or visit home for political reasons. It means a lot to you when you get a permanent, legal home again.
- dangoldin 13y agoI expected this to be something more abstract so the concrete examples of factual inaccuracies were interesting. My dad claims to have answered that the US was a financial oligarchy when asked what type of government the US had on his citizenship test but I suspect that was a joke.
- bradleyjg 13y agoThere's a famous story, possibly apocryphal, about Kurt Gödel going to his citizenship exam accompanied by Einstein and another friend. The story goes that he had studied the Constitution and come to the conclusion that it was flawed, and contained a loophole that would allow the President to become a dictator (given the role the Weimar Constitution played in Hitler rise to power, this would not have been an altogether silly concern). He wanted to explain that the to the judge who was examining him, but he was finally convinced by his friends that it wouldn't be a good idea.
- 6cxs2hd6 13y agoGödel believed there could be a complete and consistent set of axioms for government? :)
- wmoser 13y agoI've taken numerous (1 EPA, 2 FCC, 16 USCG) government administered tests and they are all have these poorly written, blatantly wrong answers. Fortunately, with larger question pools and more questions on a test it doesn't throw your final score off if you get one or two where the wrong answer. I wouldn't want to take a test with 100 question pool and only 10 questions.