23 ms·
I think that headline is slightly misleading - Google is running an argument in court that as their service is supplied from the US then they can't be sued here
by arethuza 13y ago
I think that headline is slightly misleading - Google is running an argument in court that as their service is supplied from the US then they can't be sued here in the UK.
If the courts decide otherwise then Google has quite a lot of assets here in the UK in the form of Google UK Limited - obviously tiny compared to the US parent but still a pretty substantial organization by any objective measure.
I tend to side with the claimants (I believe that is the correct term in England - it is pursuer here in Scotland) that as they have a .co.uk site and substantial operations here in the UK they should be directly subject to litigation in the UK. If they were a US only operation then fair enough - it would seem silly to sue them here in the UK, but they have long outgrown that status.
- yapcguy 13y agoBegs the question, so what exactly does the Google UK office actually do again?! Google "operates" in the UK, the second biggest market for advertising revenue yet manages to book their profits in Ireland because that's where their sales are "signed". Yet even that Dublin office has no profit as they have expenses to pay to the tune of billions in IP to a patent-holding Google subsidiary in Bermuda. This must me a wake up call to quite a lot of people. It used to be that it was only poor countries that got shafted by foreign corporations (e.g. Dow Chemical, Bhopal disaster in India). Now, it's -gasp- happening to us too!
- brainsic 13y agoIt might come as a shock to you but people (and corporations) try to win in court, arguing over jurisdiction is an automatic first step - nothing extraordinary is happening here. And if you need someone to point for you the difference between this no harm money/publicly seeking bullshit lawsuit, and chemical spill disasters then you lack all perspective.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- chc 13y agoI agree with your point, but I'm not sure the hostility is really necessary.
- gress 13y agoIt it your perspective that intentionally violating user privacy causes no harm?
- patrickaljord 13y agoGoogle is not violating anyone's privacy unless you've already decided they're guilty. Moreover, no one's forced to use google services. If anyone is violating people's privacy without their consents, it would be the government.
- gress 13y agoWhether Google is guilty or not has nothing to do with the seriousness of the accusation which the parent was trying to dismiss, and nowhere do I presume them guilty. However Google settled the same accusation by acknowledging the action and paying a fine to the FCC, so the only question is whether what they have done is illegal, not whether they did it. Directing attention to the government is a false dichotomy which makes it seem like you're trying to protect Google from scrutiny. Both can be guilty. We don't pardon thieves because they aren't as bad as murderers. Also nobody being forced to use google's services is irrelevant. The question is whether Google deceived those who did make that choice. If you think the best remedy is for users to make their own choice about using Google services, don't you want these behaviors to be exposed and publicly scrutinized so that users can make an informed decision?
- brainsic 13y agoFTC != FCC. Also Google didn't admit guilt in said settlement. It's not a question of deception, it's about a bug that was patched once disclosed with no indication to it being anything other than a mistake. It's a petty case brought by petty people, and your factless defence of their "cause" is puzzling.
- belorn 13y ago> If they were a US only operation then fair enough - it would seem silly to sue them here in the UK. That seems a bit odd in a legal way. If a user breaks into Google servers, we don't care where the server is located. Why should the location of the server matter if its the server operators that do the crime? Shouldn't the same laws rule everyone equally?
- brainsic 13y agoSaid "user"s lawyer can certainly argue on bases of jurisdiction as well. Also there is no "crime" here, it's all preliminary stuff.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThey also include this in their Terms of Service[1] - "All claims arising out of or relating to these terms or the Services will be litigated exclusively in the federal or state courts of Santa Clara County, California, USA, and you and Google consent to personal jurisdiction in those courts. " Which basically says if you use Google services you agree that any dispute you have with Google will be litigated in a California court. This particular clause has been upheld several times for Google. [1] http://www.google.com/intl/en/policies/terms/ http://www.google.com/intl/en/policies/terms/
- arethuza 13y agoJust because something is in a contract (or indeed a terms of service) doesn't mean it is enforceable - especially in a completely different country. If Google were a US only corporation then this would be a moot point, but as the aren't they are subject to the laws and courts of the countries where they operate. Given that they are actually in court someone clearly thinks there is a stateable case - it'll be interesting to see what the court decides. Edit: Here is an update from the Telegraph: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/google/10520755/Britons-should-be-able-to-sue-Google-for-privacy-breaches-court-hears.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/google/10520755/Briton...
- DerpDerpDerp 13y agoI'm not sure this would even hold up internal to the US. A state could likely decide that by doing business in that state (eg, having offices located there) that Google was subject to its laws when dealing with residents of that state. Contracts of adhesion aren't always enforceable.
- ChuckMcM 13y ago[1] http://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2013/11/googles-forum-selection-clause-upheld-again-rudgayzer-v-google.htm http://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2013/11/googles-forum-s...