3 ms·
I thought this article's title sounded stupid at first, so I began reading, and this gem just popped out at me: "Imagine how much worse off the country might b
by peterwwillis 13y ago
I thought this article's title sounded stupid at first, so I began reading, and this gem just popped out at me:
"Imagine how much worse off the country might be if the 49ers had decided against making the trek to California or the sharecroppers chose to stay in the South."
I'm assuming by '49ers' he means the gold rush of 1849, many of whom took a chance on coming out to the west to try and find gold. But sharecroppers?
Sharecroppers didn't "choose" to move away from the south. They were basically poor uneducated people without any other form of work available to them. A good portion of them were the direct descendents of slaves who used to work the same land in the same way. They lost their indentured servitude when they became obsoleted by the mechanization of farming. There were no other jobs in the area, but as luck would have it, a big push for more industrial workers was happening in the north and west.
That's not some kind of "admirable trait". They had no choice but to go find work elsewhere, and were lucky to find it. You don't have to be an economist to figure out that today, people aren't going to be spending lots of money they don't have to move around the country for jobs that don't exist.
We live in a global marketplace now, and almost all of our exports are things machines assemble for us. Unskilled labor is shrinking fast. Our economy is weak. Our government is hobbled. Our education sucks. Our healthcare gets exponentially more expensive. The only incentive I can think of to move is for educated people to move toward centers of white-collar business for the remaining and new jobs, and maybe gentrification away from expensive metropolises people can no longer afford.
So yeah, NYT, we're not going anywhere.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoNorth Dakota has 2.7% unemployment. Nevada has 9.3%. On a per-county level the disparities become even bigger. Jobs exist elsewhere, people have just stopped moving to them. The article isn't stupid, they clearly looked at the stats.
- ars_technician 13y agoWhy let stats get in the way of a feel-good rant?
- peterwwillis 13y agoYes, different places have different unemployment rates. And different states have different industries, some of which were hit worse than others, and some of which are slowly recovering as there's renewed interest in certain exports. But I have no idea how the unemployment stats of two states applies to available jobs and moving to them. The entire subject is based on finding specific available work in remote places and being able to afford the transition. I don't see how unemployment figures give any insight to such a correlation.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoIn the case of North Dakota, the jobs are unskilled jobs in the oil industry. They are paying tons of money because no one is moving to ND. Australia has similar issues and allows Americans to move there for mining and hospitality jobs. The stats aren't perfect, but they are certainly indicative.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoYou're right that the association between unemployment rates and available jobs can be problematic. A 55 year old unemployed office worker from Nevada will not be able to fix fracking equipment in the Bakken Shale. But if the unemployment rate falls to extremely low levels as it has in North Dakota it means that job availability has trickled down from one specific booming industry to basically everything. So there will be a job opening for that 55 year old office worker. Still, it's possible that rents there are sky high and it might not make economic sense to move just to take a job at a burger joint.
- MAGZine 13y agoin these places, even when the rent is sky-high, the burger joints pay a pretty penny, too. however, they're typically enormously unfavorable to live in.
- MaysonL 13y agoYes, but given that the number of job openings is about a third the size of the number of unemployed, the sanity of moving hoping to find a job when you get there is not high.
- ds9 13y agoIt's not even a choice for a lot of people. Posters on HN, it seems are generally in IT, middle class, in demand and in many cases even get moving costs paid by a new employer. A large percentage of lower class workers literally can't afford to move themselves and a a few suitcases, and those a little higher on the scale can't afford to travel for interviews, or are unwilling to sell most of their possessions to reduce the cost of moving, as the replacement cost would take a long time to be outbalanced by a better job. There is also the fear of not finding a new job, even in an area with a better market, if they can't (afford to) line up one in advance. The NYT article is basically the capitalist class whining that the workers' stubborn attachement to their own meagre interests is interfering with corporations having a ready supply of cheap labor wherever they want to set up.
- mynewwork 13y agoPedantic, but I think far more HN people are developers working in R&D rather than administrators working in IT. I wouldn't be surprised to see there are more people working in product marketing than IT too for that matter.
- bluedino 13y agoWhy move when you can stay put and the government keeps extending benefits?
- awkward 13y agoNorth Dakota has less than a quarter the population of Nevada. The real numbers of jobs available there aren't going to employ a significant percentage of Nevadans.