3 ms·
One factor not mentioned in the article is the two-body problem: In a society where most families have two incomes, moving is only possible after finding two jo
by cperciva 13y ago
One factor not mentioned in the article is the two-body problem: In a society where most families have two incomes, moving is only possible after finding two jobs in the same area.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoWhat's blocking the move? If I lifted you up and put you down in Austin, are you saying you'd be completely unable to find work? If one single person can move first and find a job second, why can't one married person do the same (on the assumption that the other one has already found a job)?
- cperciva 13y agoI don't know why you're being downvoted, these seem like reasonable questions to me. If I lifted you up and put you down in Austin, are you saying you'd be completely unable to find work? No, but I'd certainly prefer to find work before moving. If one single person can move first and find a job second, why can't one married person do the same (on the assumption that the other one has already found a job)? There are a lot of dual-income couples who would be severely stressed by losing one of their incomes.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe last point is key. A lot of two income couples upgrade their lifestyle, taking on a much riskier financial profile in order to consume more. Relocating when only one person has a job would result in a large decrease in consumption - from a house/car/groceries to a smaller house, cheaper car and trader joe instead of whole foods.
- omaranto 13y agooff-topic: Trader Joe's is cheaper than Whole Foods? I guess I am to poor to notice that! I can't afford to shop at either one and just go there for occasionally luxury items like wine or cheese.
- yebyen 13y agoI guess I am lucky to have an Aldi in the neighborhood No alcohol, but it's the same ownership as Trader Joe's I think (and cheaper, also with lots of good cheese) I live a three minute walk from Wegmans but I would rather drive to Aldi's; you don't escape Wegmans with three bags of groceries for $40-60.
- michaelt 13y agoWell, there's "completely unable to find work" and there's "unable to find good enough work to make the move worthwhile" - especially if your salary (or lifelong dreams) depend on you using your unusual specialist skills. Let's say I'm an expert in discovering new drugs, and my partner is a dancer for a professional ballet company. For me to take a job that ended her professional career (or vice-versa) the payoff would have to be huge.
- caw 13y agoYes, if you both want to keep your meaningful work it generally ends up being the more scarce opportunity determining where you move. That's assuming there is a location where jobs X and Y both exist. For example, my friend is a civil engineer. There's lots of civil engineering jobs in the US, but his wife works as a chemical engineer. Chemical engineering jobs are largely where either oil/gas deposits are, or large amounts of water (water for processing and/or waterways/railroad for shipping). So I imagine for them it will be where ever she needs to move he'll need to follow, versus the other way around, lest they end up in some place where she can't use the degree she spent 4 years getting.
- mslate 13y agoSome might suspect that the proliferation of two-earner couples is an explanation. Surely having a spouse who works can make it more difficult to pursue job opportunities in distant places. Yet the percentage of married households with two earners has hardly changed over the last thirty years. Instead, the relevant change is that today’s two-paycheck married households are about 46 percent less likely to move across state lines than were their counterparts in the 1980s. From a previous article on the subject: http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/magazine/november_december_2013/features/stay_put_young_man047332.php?page=all http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/magazine/november_december_...
- cperciva 13y agothe percentage of married households with two earners has hardly changed over the last thirty years Interesting, but not necessarily enough to rule out a connection -- I would expect a spouse who works part-time in a low-wage would provide less friction than a spouse who works full-time in a professional capacity. Women (let's be honest, that's mostly who we're talking about here) may not have increased their penetration of the job market over the past few decades, but they have certainly moved upwards -- and into jobs which are harder to drop on short notice.
- yardie 13y ago> the percentage of married households with two earners has hardly changed over the last thirty years. I think the statement just barely covers what 2 incomes mean in the 80s verses now. It's far easier to move if one skilled and one unskilled partner find a new job. A scientist and a secretary for example. It's much more complicated when 2 partners have career and salary parity.
- jzwinck 13y agoStrangely, two people who each earn a high income may find it harder to move within the US, yet they may also find it easier to move outside the US, relative to two-income couples with a larger wage gap. This is because many countries offer work visas for "high skilled" or "in demand" jobs and require each person to qualify independently. So while a programmer and a cook may find it relatively easy to move between cities or states, the lower-earning partner would be denied the right to work in some other countries. Whether that makes economic sense for those other countries I am not sure. It does make some political sense: the high-earning locals can find work anywhere, but low-earning ones are more likely going to stay in their own country, where they would prefer not to compete with foreigners. Not every country works this way; the UK for example grants many spouses and partners the right to work (but read about their new "12 month cooling off period" before you apply!).