3 ms·
"[I]t is slavery to force one out of the market and no longer be productive or do anything for society." While I wouldn't put it in such strong terms, I agree
by dllthomas 13y ago
"[I]t is slavery to force one out of the market and no longer be productive or do anything for society."
While I wouldn't put it in such strong terms, I agree that is a horrible thing. I don't think it's at all what a basic income would do - especially a modest one. Doubly so in contrast to our current welfare (including disability) system.
Basic Income is not contingent on you not working. If you can find some clients that are willing to pay you a little in exchange for some work you're happy to do, you take home the money they pay you on top of the Basic Income.
"I can just see people dropping out of high school in large numbers to stay at home with their parents, avoid taking a job, just apply for basic income and get that low income AT&T DSL Internet for $15/month and play video games on a cheap PC or used Playstation or used XBox for the rest of their lives and never contribute anything for the betterment their lives and help out others."
If their parents will stand for it, I'm sure that will happen some. But most people do like to feel productive, and most parents prefer to see their children doing something useful, and them doing something useful - for pay or otherwise - does not decrease the Basic Income stipend.
- orionblastar 13y agoWhat good is basic income if it does not encourage people on it to learn new things and find new sources of income or look for a job? What if basic income makes a majority of people not learn anything and just never learn from their mistakes and failures, and always have that basic income safety net to rely on even if all they do is play video games, get drunk every day, get stoned every day, abuse people every day, and just become a jerk to everyone because they have no responsibilities at all? I don't think this basic income (while it does sound nice) has not been properly thought through. Do you have any peer reviewed sources on it that I can learn more about it? Apparently this is a 'hot issue' as my parent post was downvoted into oblivion for raising doubts about it.
- dllthomas 13y ago"What good is basic income if it does not encourage people on it to learn new things and find new sources of income or look for a job?" I dispute the notion that fear of significant poverty is the only thing that can motivate people to do such things (or the best way to do it). "What if basic income makes a majority of people not learn anything and just never learn from their mistakes and failures, and always have that basic income safety net to rely on even if all they do is play video games, get drunk every day, get stoned every day, abuse people every day, and just become a jerk to everyone because they have no responsibilities at all?" I don't see how our current system prevents abusing people in any way that our system plus basic income would not. Regarding the others, I think escapist overindulgence in these things (and anything else on offer) is a problem we need better mechanisms for confronting. I don't think limiting people's resources is a necessary, sufficient, effective, or appropriate approach. Oftentimes people fall into these habits because they feel there is nothing they can do to improve their situation. "I don't think this basic income (while it does sound nice) has not been properly thought through. Do you have any peer reviewed sources on it that I can learn more about it?" I'm sure there've been plenty of economics papers in journals through the years, given that Milton Friedman was an avid proponent. Regarding an actual experiment with Basic Income: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mincome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mincome