3 ms·
This argument would only be valid if bitcoin were the only currency, or weren't easily convertible to and from dollars. People invested in bitcoins still have
by DennisP 13y ago
This argument would only be valid if bitcoin were the only currency, or weren't easily convertible to and from dollars.
People invested in bitcoins still have to buy things. What many of them do is leave their investment in place, convert a few dollars to bitcoins and spend those.
Of course they have an incentive to save rather than spend bitcoins, but this incentive applies equally well to their dollars. If they expect bitcoin deflation to continue, they should convert their dollars to bitcoins rather than spending their dollars. If bitcoin's deflation isn't preventing people from spending dollars, it's not preventing them from spending bitcoins either.
Bitcoin isn't having a strong effect on dollars, because its total value is only about $10 billion. Maybe someday it will have a strong deflationary effect on the dollar economy, but it'll have to get much bigger before that happens.
But once it is that big, its rate of deflation will slow. It's high now because its usage is growing[1] so quickly. In the past seven days, the number of bitcoin-accepting merchants on coinmap grew 13%. That radical growth will eventually slow, and then we won't see such drastic price changes.
Arguably it will still be somewhat deflationary, but even that isn't a sure thing since bitcoin won't necessarily be the only successful cryptocurrency. Hayek argued that private competing currencies would result in price stability without central control, and we might find out whether he was right.
[1] http://www.bitcoinpulse.com http://www.bitcoinpulse.com
- maxerickson 13y agoIt's telling that none of those indicators relate to the value of the goods that are being purchased with Bitcoin. That's probably the most interesting metric.
- DennisP 13y agoIt would definitely be interesting. I'm having trouble thinking of a way that metric could be gathered with any reliability, given that merchants typically generate new bitcoin addresses for each purchase.