3 ms·
> The big idea is that boys and girls, especially at high school age learn/are motivated in fundamentally different ways so splitting them and teaching them in
by XorNot 13y ago
> The big idea is that boys and girls, especially at high school age learn/are motivated in fundamentally different ways so splitting them and teaching them in different ways could be more effective.
This idea is even more harmful. The differences within the group are greater then the differences between the groups - but by trying to split the environments along enormously broad divisions, you're ensuring you marginalize huge swathes of people in addition to creating an unhealthy socialization environment.
The reality here is once you let in the idea that gender has something to say about people beyond what their genitals look like, you're letting in any number of other harmful ideas. It's no coincidence that girl's only highschools mysteriously lack shop-classes, for example but always have Home Ec.
- tinco 13y ago> The reality here is once you let in the idea that gender has something to say about people beyond what their genitals look like It would be ignorant to think otherwise. There are differences between sexes beyond the genitalia. That is not a harmful idea, that is a fact. The harmful idea is that any of the sexes should be denied any opportunity, like a shop-class or Home Ec. That would be equal to denial of education, and I'm proud to say we've moved past that in the past 40 years.
- Mikera 13y agoIt concerns me when people confuse the idea of gender equality and rights (which I think most reasonable people agree is a good thing) with the idea that men and women's lives have to be the same in all aspects. I think it is much more harmful to impose a dogmatic belief that forces everyone to lead identical, mono-cultured lives and denies individual choice. What if I want to go to a single-sex school? Who are you to deny me that choice?
- XorNot 13y agoWho's denying it to you? But the same thing you complain abiut ia also ehxactly what single-sex schools are doing - its not about looking at your interests and learning style based on your home envitonment, test scores, and social proclivites to tey and find an optimum learning environmwnt for you - its about seeing if you have a penis and declaring that obviously you must 'learn competitively' and its very important we advocate you running around outside. Because clearly girls don't do those things. I'm sadly never surprised that the cinclusions people draw about gendered education just so happen to reinforce societal gender stereotypes.