5 ms·
I've done a couple successful Kickstarters for my comics. Here is some critique about your campaign, which might help explain why you're at 6% of your goal with
by egypturnash 13y ago
I've done a couple successful Kickstarters for my comics. Here is some critique about your campaign, which might help explain why you're at 6% of your goal with half the time left.
I have never heard of "bob's game". So all this stuff about it being the game from inside the "legendary" "bob's game" just befuddles me. Big Kickstarter tip: assume that most of the people coming to your page will have never heard of you, or a single thing you've done, and make your pitch accordingly.
The video doesn't make this look too much fun; is it actually presented in this tournament view with a dude wandering around trash-talking you, and really annoying crowd audio loops over it? And occasional random green lights drifting around the picture of a monitor on the screen? Because the game looks kind of pretty in an abstract way, but that endless loop of a screeching crowd and three seconds of music makes me want to throw something through my speakers after a few minutes. It could be kinda fun to trance out to this thing if I was just looking at the actual game screen and hearing its noises, but given that all the screenshots match this video I'm going to assume it's got this super obnoxious frame around it all the time.
And what's going on in the video? I dunno. Where's some text telling me about the cool features of this game? I'm watching some blobs get dropped in a well, and there seem to be no consistent rules, or cues that the rules are changing. The shapes change, the effects change, and there's no rhyme or reason. Playing a game whose rules are constantly changing under me with no warning really doesn't sound like fun. The text suggests that this is actually one of the unique selling points of this game - convince me in your pitch that this is actually a cool thing instead of something that will constantly frustrate me.
Who are you? Why do you want to make this game? How passionate about making it are you? This is a crucial component of a good KS video: seeing the face(s) behind the idea, hearing the enthusiasm in their voice at the idea of getting to actually make this thing. Learning something about their credentials - what have you delivered before, why should I be convinced you've got what it takes to actually give me something?
Tiers: $4 for the game. $25 for beta/forum access. These tiers aren't doing much for you. Assume that nobody will ever pledge anything more than the base "gimme the thing" level, how many backers will you need? 1667 backers. That is insane. If the price for actually getting the game was $25, you'd have a much more feasible number of 265 backers.
Really, this feels like the only market for this is total ultra obsessive Tetris fans. I play drop-stuff-in-a-well games every now and then, but I'm honestly not moved by this pitch to even try playing a demo of it (which doesn't seem to exist anywhere?), much less spend any money on it.
Good luck, but I don't think you're going to come anywhere near success with this campaign. Scrap it and start again, after remaking your pitch and workshopping the hell out of it.
- bobsgame 13y agoThere are only 14 hours left, not half the time, so this is the last chance for it to succeed. I doubt I will make another Kickstarter. I don't have the equipment or resources to really edit a better video. I think it's important to just let the product speak for itself. I really believe in the game and that it is the first puzzle game that is genuinely better than Tetris, which is perhaps the most difficult game development feat. The tournament setting will not be there in the OUYA version, it is the final scene from the "bob's game" RPG. I haven't had the chance to make a build outside of that context yet. I want to keep the game very inexpensive so that many OUYA owners will buy it and make it more fun for everyone by having a larger tournament pool, and I can't really offer any greater value than the game itself. I don't feel right selling a poster or a t-shirt for more than the game, since the game itself took so much more effort. I appreciate your critique and I understand where you are coming from and why your suggestions are successful, but I don't have the resources to do what you're suggesting, which is why I'm doing the Kickstarter in the first place- which is really in the original spirit of Kickstarter itself.
- egypturnash 13y agoI shot the video for my pitches with the camera in my Mac, and edited it with a demo copy of Final Cut. I probably could have done it with iMovie, to be honest, except I got sick of trying to do some complex camera moves on still images in iMovie. Also if the tournament setting won't be there in the actual product then why on earth is it in the video and images? IMHO it's actively driving people away from your game. Present what you're intending to actually deliver. Oh, and the easy higher tier to draw larger donors in: Your Name In The Credits. Name A Game Mode. Name A Level. Etc, etc.
- bobsgame 13y agoI could probably edit video with a non-trivial degree of frustration, but I am honestly sort of philosophically opposed to making a "proper" Kickstarter campaign and I want to keep it as simple as I can even though it is not the best approach. I haven't really been able to make a build outside the context of the RPG yet. Originally I had a "name in the credits" tier but decided to remove it, because I didn't know how to handle it for future versions of the game. Everyone is supposed to be able to make their own level/mode, so that's out.