3 ms·
"How much control do we take away though?" I think it's less about "how much do we take away", and more about "if we automate this, will we train dangerous hab
by bigiain 13y ago
"How much control do we take away though?"
I think it's less about "how much do we take away", and more about "if we automate this, will we train dangerous habits into pilots who use it?"
You don't tech you junior sysadmins to use "rm -rf /" to delete user data "because Unix prevents you from deleting files not owned by you, so it's perfectly safe!" _one day_ that sysadmin is going to be logged in as root.
I have no idea whether the pilot here was trained to let an Airbus override dangerous actions on his part or not - but if he _was_ – _that's_ something that ought to be considered for changing.
We wouldn't let a car manufacturer sell a car with the brake pedal on the right and the accelerator on the left - because no matter how diligently you tell buyers, or how prominently you point it out in the owners manual, somebody is going to mash that accelerator pedal in an emergency expecting the car to stop.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI agree! Personally, I would rather fly on a plane with no pilot that's driven completely with UAV guts from takeoff to landing. Yes, there will be edge cases where there will be failures. I just believe those cases will be far fewer than pilot error. AND with the resulting data, we can prevent those same edge cases from occurring again.
- gaius 13y agoNot for you tho', as getting the data killed you!
- toomuchtodo 13y agoStill an improvement over people. You know what goes wrong, but you have no guarantee other pilots own't make the mistake again, even with training and education.
- JHof 13y agoUAVs are still piloted. They're just controlled from the ground.
- bigiain 13y ago<cynical thought>Remotely piloted by guys who aren't sitting at the pointy end of 100 tons of jetfuel doing 600mph, and therefore might not be quite as well motivated to succeed as their in-jetliner colleagues…
- toomuchtodo 13y agoNot all UAVs: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_X-47B http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_X-47B The X-47B receives commands from the flight deck, but is not directly piloted. It not only can be catapulted from an aircraft carrier, fly its mission, and return with no human input, it can also autonomously on-air refuel from a tanker with no human pilot on the ground.
- JHof 13y agoMaybe piloted is the wrong word. It's not AI. They're still directed and monitored by an operator.