13 ms·
> It's disingenuous to say that he abandoned ship because he was mistreated because other people of the same ethnicity were spies? What kind of insane reasonin
by gwern 13y ago
> It's disingenuous to say that he abandoned ship because he was mistreated because other people of the same ethnicity were spies? What kind of insane reasoning is that?
It's non-naive reasoning based on the knowledge that yes, people do care about their own race and ethnicity and may have multiple loyalties, and the world doesn't work based on a simple 'you are 100% loyal to the country you are in' bit of reasoning.
Try engaging in less abuse and more probabilistic reasoning.
> Either there are good reasons to believe he was a spy, or there are not.
Either this is a false dichotomy, or it is not.
> If there are, then let's hear what they are, but "other Chinese people were spies" is not remotely a good reason.
Yes, it is. If other Chinese people were spies at above base-rates, then one will be more accurate in finding traitors by taking this into account.
- mikeash 13y agoGiven that it seems he was quite loyal until he was persecuted by his country, how do you think that reasoning turned out in the end?