3 ms·
Scott Aaronson on Philosophical Progress
- jere 13y agoScott Adams: "Passion is bullshit...My own experience is that when stuff works, I get really excited about it. Passion follows success. Scott Aaronson: " The obvious thing to say is that, as a student, you should follow your talents and passions, rather than following the generic advice of some guy on the Internet who doesn’t even know you personally!"
- waterlesscloud 13y agoWouldn't following your talents overlap heavily with getting excited about things that work for you?
- jerf 13y agoNow we just need a Scott Abernathy (or similar last name) so we can get a quote that goes something like "As usual, the answer lies somewhere in the middle." Anybody here fit the bill?
- dasil003 13y agoAaronson's talking about a much narrower field than Adams though. While success might beget passion in the case of science, I think that would happen in childhood and the seed would already be planted. If you make it to adulthood and pursue a career in theoretical science then I think you must have a very deep well of not only passion, but probably obsession to have any success at all.
- bsirkia 13y agoThis article reminds me of "Zen and The Art of Motorcycle Maintenance", specifically when the author explains that he really struggled with the idea that as we learn more, we gain a better understanding of how little we know. As Aaronson says, "the subquestions aren’t nearly as small as they originally looked", and Prisig had a tough time reconciling the idea that as humanity's body of knowledge grew, the number of answered questions grew even faster.
- thenerdfiles 13y agoDoes "formal intelligence" mean that construction is involved in its development?
- thenerdfiles 13y agohttps://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/47805860/Scott-Aaronson-on-Philosophical-Progress.md.ogg https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/47805860/Scott-Aaronson-...
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago>One final note: none of the positive or hopeful things that I said about philosophy apply to the postmodern or Continental kinds. As far as I can tell, the latter aren’t really “philosophy” at all, but more like pretentious brands of performance art that fancy themselves politically subversive, even as they cultivate deliberate obscurity and draw mostly on the insights of Hitler and Stalin apologists. As someone who regularly rereads about the Sokal Hoax for laughs, I had to stop myself breaking down here.