6 ms·
I would not forget that he was co-founder of China's missile program too. And given how many Chinese-Americans turn out to be passing secrets to China, it's pre
by gwern 13y ago
I would not forget that he was co-founder of China's missile program too. And given how many Chinese-Americans turn out to be passing secrets to China, it's pretty disingenuous to go 'oh, he only worked for them because the US mistreated him!' He would be far from the first person whose loyalties turned out to lie where you would expect them to lie.
Let them go home? This issue has come up before. The Feds locked up H. S. Tsien [Qian Xuesen] back in the 50s because they thought he was pro-Chinese and would aid the Chinese rocket program. When they finally let him go, that’s exactly what he did.
There have been many cases in which key individuals have been allowed to go home and fight with their homies, due to chivalry or some other form of stupidity. in 1861, the Feds let many officers go home and fight for the Confederacy. Radomir Putnik, chief of the Serbian general staff, was taking the waters in Austria when the First World War broke out. They let him go home – were they ever sorry! Gernot Zippe, an Austrian POW in a Siberian camp, built a workable centrifuge for separating isotopes. Yet, to my lasting surprise, the Soviets let him go in 1956. He became the Johnny Appleseed of nuclear proliferation [along with Eisenhower - Atoms for Peace].
https://westhunt.wordpress.com/2013/10/01/who-can-you-trust/ https://westhunt.wordpress.com/2013/10/01/who-can-you-trust/
- mikeash 13y agoIt's disingenuous to say that he abandoned ship because he was mistreated because other people of the same ethnicity were spies? What kind of insane reasoning is that? Either there are good reasons to believe he was a spy, or there are not. If there are not, then it's absolutely reasonable to say that he went to China because he was mistreated. If there are, then let's hear what they are, but "other Chinese people were spies" is not remotely a good reason.
- gwern 13y ago> It's disingenuous to say that he abandoned ship because he was mistreated because other people of the same ethnicity were spies? What kind of insane reasoning is that? It's non-naive reasoning based on the knowledge that yes, people do care about their own race and ethnicity and may have multiple loyalties, and the world doesn't work based on a simple 'you are 100% loyal to the country you are in' bit of reasoning. Try engaging in less abuse and more probabilistic reasoning. > Either there are good reasons to believe he was a spy, or there are not. Either this is a false dichotomy, or it is not. > If there are, then let's hear what they are, but "other Chinese people were spies" is not remotely a good reason. Yes, it is. If other Chinese people were spies at above base-rates, then one will be more accurate in finding traitors by taking this into account.
- mikeash 13y agoGiven that it seems he was quite loyal until he was persecuted by his country, how do you think that reasoning turned out in the end?
- wozniacki 13y agoI'm certain that there surely are damning cases where Chinese-Americans were convicted of treasonous high crimes. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/spy/leung/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/spy/leung/ http://www.apnewsarchive.com/1990/Report-Stolen-Secrets-May-Have-Helped-China-Build-Neutron-Bomb/id-4cf0594e1ee9638fba6531c67ce0ed13 http://www.apnewsarchive.com/1990/Report-Stolen-Secrets-May-... But then there are also cases like that of Wen Ho Lee where there was significant prosecutorial overreach. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wen_Ho_Lee http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wen_Ho_Lee Four Chinese Espionage Investigations Details of four investigations into suspected Chinese espionage over the past 20 years -- only one of which was prosecuted successfully -- revealing the complexities of such cases. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/spy/spies/four.html http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/spy/spies/four... Edit: Corrected URL
- yapcguy 13y agoQian was a co-founder and very first Director of the JPL, recognised by his peers as being a genius. He didn't need to be a spy, he had everything in his head. His wife even says that he wanted to become a naturalized US citizen. "Sent to Germany to interrogate Nazi scientists, Qian interviewed rocket scientist Wernher von Braun. As the trade magazine Aviation Week put it in 2007, upon naming Qian its person of the year, "No one then knew that the father of the future U.S. space program was being quizzed by the father of the future Chinese space program." No evidence was presented, he was never tried or convicted of being a spy. Imagine being at the height of your powers and than being wrongly accused of a crime, and for five years not being able to work with your peers. Science was the loser here. Today's media reports on the moon landing refer to China's "military backed" space program. Duh. Instead of celebrating science, it's sad to see people rolling out little slurs and digs which are intended to discredit China and its achievements. I won't say it's racist but it sure looks like it.
- ryanhuff 13y agoI won't say it's racist but it sure looks like it. But you did say it, and its ridiculous. How exactly is this supposed to be "racist"? You don't think if Qian was Russian, and this was the 1950's that the government wouldn't have done something similar? The government can (and does) make decisions out of fear, and that's probably what was going on in this case.
- beachstartup 13y ago> You don't think if Qian was Russian, and this was the 1950's that the government wouldn't have done something similar? yeah, more or less. Wernher von Braun (1912-1977), technical director of Nazi Germany's missile program, became the United States' lead rocket engineer during the 1950s and 1960s this guy was a former nazi, AND his home country of germany was a soviet satellite state, he seemed to escape suspicion. so this guy was a nazi and a communist, but he was all good. no problems here! gee. i wonder why. there were also many soviet defectors that were never chased out of the country. this is because he was chinese, plain and simple. doesn't look like us = not one of us. that was the thinking back in the day. i wouldn't be surprised if it turns out that his accusors simply didn't think a chinese person could be smart enough to be a rocket scientist, either. people actually thought this way back in the 50s.
- mng2 13y agoIris Chang's biography of Tsien argues that the government backed him into a corner, then left him in bureaucratic limbo for several years. This would be a lot for a proud, brilliant man to take sitting down. I find it easier to believe that he was deeply insulted by the accusations made against him, and after enduring several years of uncertainty, chose the pit over the pendulum.
- gwern 13y agoYou can choose what you find easier to believe. But let's not pretend that Tsien was obviously innocent and it must have been the government's fault. I'm sure Chang is sympathetic to her subject and would like to argue that it's all the government's fault.
- walid 13y agoLooking at it through your lens: if he stays he's a spy, if he leaves he's a spy. Any third option?
- beachstartup 13y agoyeah. the third option is be born white.
- gwern 13y agoFalse dichotomy. He had many options: he could've fought the deportation, he could've gone elsewhere than China, he could've gone to China and not worked in their ICBMs, etc.
- walid 13y agoThe article does mention that he did fight deportation. On the other hand not going to China or working on Chinese rocket projects would have been ludicrous considering his ethnicity and field of expertise. You expect a human to simply drop their life's opus because of accusations of being a communist. Frankly it doesn't matter if he was or wasn't a communist. It doesn't matter in the larger scope of things because being a communist doesn't mean betraying your country. The question is why was he charged with communism (which is not a crime) without proof. Any charge without prior proof is over reach. And him ending in China is the best option he had after being stalled in the USA.
- gwern 13y ago> The article does mention that he did fight deportation. And that he dropped it: "He later changed course, however, and sought to return to China." > On the other hand not going to China or working on Chinese rocket projects would have been ludicrous considering his ethnicity and field of expertise. Why couldn't he go to Europe or any of the other countries in the world which are not China? And when he went to China, why did he work on what he did? It's possible to work in NASA rather than NSA. > The question is why was he charged with communism (which is not a crime) without proof. Any charge without prior proof is over reach. He apparently was not an American citizen (eg "Qian was born in the eastern city of Hangzhou, and in 1934 graduated from Jiaotong University in Shanghai, where he studied mechanical engineering."). You are applying the incorrect standards.
- beachstartup 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aldrich_Ames http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aldrich_Ames http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Hanssen http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Hanssen white guys with european ancestry are the 2 worst spies in the history of the US. did their loyalties lie where you "expected" them to lie?
- gwern 13y agoYes. Please consider that like 99% of the intelligence community is white. We should expect to see 99 Ames or Hanssens for every Xuesen. I know statistics is hard, but seriously, this should be an obvious point. The relevant agencies are almost completely white especially in the era we're talking about; doesn't this imply that any spies are almost certainly going to be white and that more than 2 or 3 Chinese spies indicate that loyalties may be... divided? Look at the WP list, it's well beyond 2.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- beachstartup 13y agoLOL "we're the majority so you should expect to see more of us do X, the fact that isn't true proves that minority is bad." this tired old argument and the convenient self-fulfilling prophecies it spawns can be used to justify anything. especially a persecution of any minority population for any activity whatsoever. prime example: war on drugs. let's not forget that investigations are run by people, with focused efforts on specific targets, for specific reasons. oftentimes investigators will go for the politically expedient target, the 'easy' target, or simply the targets that stick out when compared. when you look at the ranks of falsely accused spies, what do you see? just because more people are caught doing something does NOT mean that they are doing more of it in real life.
- gwern 13y ago
- swampthing 13y agoSo exactly how many Chinese-Americans (as distinguished from Chinese citizens who are in America) turn out to be passing secrets to China? Looking at the Wikipedia page for spy cases involving China: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_intelligence_operations_in_the_United_States#Spy_cases http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_intelligence_operations... There only seems to be one confirmed Chinese-American case in recent years - Chi Mak (and he was a naturalized citizen).
- gwern 13y ago> There only seems to be one confirmed Chinese-American case in recent years 'recent years'? Why did you add this qualifier? That lists 8 different cases, and this is only what has gone public; by the nature of these things, you're only seeing the surface of the iceberg. (Does anyone seriously think that the US is not the top target of Chinese espionage and where it most wants agents?) Now, consider what fraction of the populace is Chinese-American, and what that implies...
- swampthing 13y agoYou should read the list instead of just counting the entries - many of those cases turned out to be false. And yes, this is only what has gone public. You explicitly said "turn out". Do you have information that the general public does not? I said 'recent years', because does anyone consider espionage from the 80's to be relevant? I sure don't. I don't know if you realize this, but most Chinese-Americans (at least from what I've seen) were either born in the US, from Taiwan, or fled the PRC (as in, they did not want to live in a country run by the PRC). Does anyone seriously think these people are going to be spies for the Chinese government?
- gwern 13y ago> You should read the list instead of just counting the entries - many of those cases turned out to be false. No, they couldn't prove them to judicial satisfaction. That they were not shown to be guilty does not prove they were innocent. > I said 'recent years', because does anyone consider espionage from the 80's to be relevant? I sure don't. When you're considering rare events, yes, the 1980s are still relevant. Why would you exclude them? Did the Singularity happen in 1989 or are we on Mars or something? > Does anyone seriously think these people are going to be spies for the Chinese government? Does anyone seriously think that Chinese-Americans are all 100% loyal and are not a good recruiting ground for Chinese intelligence?
- yeukhon 13y agoOh yes, as a Chinese let me remind you that from news we have learned that there isn't just Chinese American accused to betray the US government, but other ethnic groups too. So, maybe all of us are guilty then. What kind of stupid idiot you are, by your stupid accusation. Because of your stupid reasoning, let me construct some ideas: By your reasoning, we should stop hiring Chinese and Russians because they are known to be hacker-active states. I should be thankful that I received a security internship back in summer and my employer should be glad I had a great chance of being a Chinese spy, injecting backdoor, because I care about my origin and I read Chinese newspaper in addition to New York Time because I happen to like NYT. And so when certain ethnic groups celebrating their ethnic holiday (Mexican, African Americans), we should be careful because they have a spiritual attachment to their origin (or their parents' origin) that they are also likely to be spy or going to be working for their mother country. Sure we can't assume they won't. I mean I see American born kids turn into terrorists and there are people who just decide they have enough of US government and run to another country (right, you know, those run to North Korean). We should also note that UK immigrants might have a tendency to take back US as UK's colonies, and Canadian should be careful of US immigrants because there is some people who believe US should own Canada too. Right?
- gyc 13y agoBetter not hire any Jewish people either because, you know, Jonathan Pollard. Thus all American Jews are suspect.
- gwern 13y ago> Oh yes, as a Chinese let me remind you that from news we have learned that there isn't just Chinese American accused to betray the US government, but other ethnic groups too. So, maybe all of us are guilty then. No. Different groups have different risks. That is the point. Someone ethnically Chinese born and raised in China has a different risk of being a spy for China than a white Mormon who has never set foot outside North America. > What kind of stupid idiot you are, by your stupid accusation. Because of your stupid reasoning, let me construct some ideas:...Right? No. Please read what I have read, and not what you think I have read. Your absolutist reasoning, without any probabilities but with tons of exaggeration, is not applicable to what I have said.