3 ms·
There may be some hypothetical situation in which there could be such a difference, but in USA politics right now, your suggestion amounts to a vapid, lame atte
by jessaustin 13y ago
There may be some hypothetical situation in which there could be such a difference, but in USA politics right now, your suggestion amounts to a vapid, lame attempt to curtail discussion. There are very few controversial policies that haven't arisen through all manner of illegal, unethical, and otherwise corrupt (what is your word, "consensus"?) processes, on all sides. If something exists in the current environment, then of course it arose at least partially through "illegitimate process", and it's certainly apropos to acknowledge the specific factual circumstances of that.
Elsewhere on this page reference is made to the "democratic" way we elect legislators and certain law enforcement officials in the USA. Polls repeatedly show clear majorities for the legalization of marijuana use, possession, and distribution. Yet somehow we still have (poor) people going to prison, and (not poor) LEOs and attorneys paying off their mortgages, due entirely to marijuana enforcement despite this wonderful process of consensus?
I guess you should just hope you always find yourself on the "majoritarian" side, if in fact you don't continuously censor and mold your own thoughts to ensure that.
- rayiner 13y ago> suggestion amounts to a vapid, lame attempt to curtail discussion. No, claiming that any popular policy you disagree with must be the product of illegitimate factors or influences is an attempt to sidestep the essential process of establishing majoritarian consensus. > Polls repeatedly show clear majorities for the legalization of marijuana use, possession, and distribution. Marijuana is a bad example for your position, because: 1) The consensus reached the point of favoring marijuana legalization just in the last few years (http://www.gallup.com/poll/165539/first-time-americans-favor-legalizing-marijuana.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/165539/first-time-americans-favor...). As recently as 2005, the Gallup poll showed that Americans were against marijuana legalization almost 2:1. And unsurprisingly, now that the consensus has shifted, you're seeing real movements all across the country to legalize marijuana. 2) The polls are still based on a random sampling of people, instead of a sampling of likely voters. People under 30 favor legalization more than 2:1, but people over 65 still somewhat oppose legalization. Guess which demographic is more likely to vote? It's not really a fault of the process if younger people don't care to participate.
- jessaustin 13y agoLook, I get it, you're very committed to this amorphous concept of "majoritarian consensus", but you shouldn't expect everyone else to be on board. Right here, we've learned majoritarian consensus implies acts that were legal for the first 150 years of the USA and will also be legal tomorrow, just happen to mean long prison terms today. Oh well, sucks to be us! That is indefensible, yet it is what your theory commits you to defend. Indeed, the essence of "majoritarian" thought seems to be caprice. Why did the prohibition of substances other than alcohol not require an analogue to the 18th Amendment? Again, sucks to be us! Oh well!
- rayiner 13y ago> implies acts that were legal for the first 150 years of the USA and will also be legal tomorrow, just happen to mean long prison terms today. It was legal for a long time for private parties to discriminate against racial minorities as well, but majoritarian consensus eventually made that illegal. Adulterating food products wasn't illegal but now is legs, most financial crimes didn't exist, etc. Society's views evolve over time and the structure of the law should keep pace. > That is indefensible, yet it is what your theory commits you to defend. What's indefensible about it? Why shouldn't people be allowed to structure their society the way they want? What makes you think that the structure people want won't change over time? The alternative is to bind people to fixed rules that they can't change, as if they're handed down from God.
- tptacek 13y agoWhat's the alternative process? You, me, and Rayiner probably don't have a lot of macro-level public policy differences, but we differ from the current state of consensus in the US. Should the US instead impanel us as Philosopher-Kings?
- tedunangst 13y agoObviously we need to bring back poll tests to prevent the sheeple from voting and ruining things for the rest of us.
- 13y ago