7 ms·
> makes a specific ask You mean ask a specific question? Or is this silicon valley jargon? edit: Through the power of The Googles I now realize he could have
by peterwwillis 13y ago
> makes a specific ask
You mean ask a specific question? Or is this silicon valley jargon?
edit:
Through the power of The Googles I now realize he could have been using the stock market form of 'ask'. It makes some sense since you're asking for an investment. Not that I like it any better...
The price a seller is willing to accept for a security,
also known as the offer price. Along with the price, the
ask quote will generally also stipulate the amount of the
security willing to be sold at that price.
http://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/ask.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/ask.asp
- javindo 13y agoDoesn't necessarily have to be jargon, it's a fairly common phrasing "would you ask that of him?" / "the client had an ask which we fulfilled". I suppose it can sound a bit biz-buzz but nothing specific to SV.
- dictum 13y ago"Would you ask that of him?" fits the normal usage of ask as a verb, though. In "the client had an ask which we fulfilled" (where ask means "request", I presume) "ask" was nounified.
- wpietri 13y agoIt is jargon. It's the thing one is going to ask for. The meaning is slightly more specific than a generic word like "request" or "desire". It implies something specific, focused, and prepared.
- peterwwillis 13y agoIf that's the case, the word 'specific' in the sentence is what makes it specific, not the phrasing. You already know they want you to provide a request for something, but you don't know it's something specific until they specify specifically. 'give a specific ask' and 'ask a specific question' are therefore equivalent, with the exception that the former looks like it was written by a 5th grader.
- dhimes 13y agowith the exception that the former looks like it was written by a 5th grader Jesus I laughed hard at this. Thank you.
- potatolicious 13y agoThey're not the same thing. An "ask" is the item being requested, it is not the question. "Can I have a cookie?" is a question, the cookie is the ask. An ask is implicitly tangible or substantial. "What's the weather today?" is a question, it doesn't really have an ask, since the item being demanded is trivial. It exists in business jargon specifically to separate minor requests "can you send me that file?" from substantial exchanges "can we update this report to include the last two quarters?" An "ask" is more "demand" than "question", without the negative connotations of demanding things from people.
- peterwwillis 13y agoAlright, so 'ask' here is just synonym for 'request', then. Looked it up... most dictionaries don't have a noun form of 'ask', though macmillan has a separate page just for it. (It's also a Scandinavian myth about the first man made from an ash tree, but that's probably not the intended use from the OP)
- meowface 13y agoI think this is the simplest definition. Swap in "request" anywhere you see "ask" (the noun) and you'll keep the exact same meaning.
- wpietri 13y agoAs I said before, the word is more specific than "request". Yes, it's an ugly term, but no, you can't make it go away by pretending it means something different.
- RickHull 13y agoI can believe you, but, having read your previous comments in this thread, I'm still not seeing the distinction between ask and request.
- oh_sigh 13y agoIt's an "almost anywhere business is done in America" jargon.
- diydsp 13y agolol "Dawn, who do we use for Chinese?" (heard approx 1997 in u.s.)
- steveklabnik 13y agoYes. Saying "I'd like to catch up with you to discuss what we've been doing at X" isn't very specific, and can be a waste of time. "I'd like to see if you'd like to get in on our seed round, we're looking for $200,000" is very specific, and waaaaay better.
- antoko 13y agoI've also heard it used in sports and such Team A are X points down and given the injury to STAR_PLAYER for them to come back now is a big ask
- gcv 13y agoIt's nasty language change which has spread, kind of like "I spoke to she about that problem" is spreading. Not specific to SV, but extremely common here.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- evacuationdrill 13y agoWhy would you say "she"? Is "her" somehow offensive now? Or have they forgotten objects of prepositions are, well, objects?
- pbreit 13y ago"ask" as a noun is fine (even outside of finance). I've never seen or heard "spoke to she" and Google doesn't seem to turn up anything.
- gcv 13y agoI hear it occasionally. I hear its equally-appalling equivalent all the time: "Please join Mary and I in welcoming John to our team." Of course, prescriptive grammar is for the birds, anyway.
- andrewaylett 13y agoThat's surely just an over-reaction to people being told "and I" in response to a sentence like "Mary and me would like to welcome John to the team". You can't win.
- aptwebapps 13y agoAs a kid, you get 'Me and Mary' as the subject corrected to 'Mary and I' for reasons of both grammar and politeness. Some people don't understand or remember the compound reason and just use 'and I' everywhere.
- Myrmornis 13y ago
- kingnight 13y agoI actually just had to look this up in a different context and came across this explanation http://english.stackexchange.com/a/4247 http://english.stackexchange.com/a/4247
- arjie 13y agoThe whole phrase means "asks for something specific". However, using words like 'something' make you sound vague even if you aren't, and using jargon like this signals "I'm in the crowd that gets you". Most people do these things without thinking. There is no 'ask' on its own and no one would refer to the ask on it's own. The entire phrase is an idiom. An ugly sounding one, but one that's here to stay, like 'day of' and 'going forward'.